80 pages • 2 hours read
Robin DiAngeloA modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more. For select classroom titles, we also provide Teaching Guides with discussion and quiz questions to prompt student engagement.
A new social binary emerged in the wake of the civil rights movement. Since racism was bad, to be racist one must be a bad person; therefore, if one was a good person, one could not be racist. This reduced the casual definition of racism “to simple, isolated, and extreme acts of prejudice” (71), meaning that nearly all white people were exempt from being identified as racists. Not only does this dichotomy falsely simplify what racism and racists are, it also makes it extremely difficult to see racism as a systemic and institutionally supported issue.
Since adopting the good/bad binary, white people in the United States have resisted being labeled racist by arguing that they are good people. DiAngelo identifies common patterns of resistance that white people display. For example: “I was taught to treat everyone the same” (81), “My parents were not racist, and they taught me not to be racist” (83), and “Focusing on race is what divides us” (86). DiAngelo describes the false narratives propping each of these common ideas up and explains how urgent it is for white people to begin undoing them.
While speaking in more generalized terms to discuss white racial identity, it is important to speak specifically about different racial identities in the United States. DiAngelo explores anti-Blackness in more depth, writing, “[i]n the white mind, black people are the ultimate racial ‘other’” (90). Without Blackness, white people could not have constructed their own superiority, so “blackness is essential to the creation of white identity” (91).
DiAngelo lists ways in which anti-Blackness is visible in contemporary American culture, including: white resistance to affirmative action programs, white acceptance of violence towards Black people, and white willingness to punish or criminalize Black people more readily.
DiAngelo discusses how anti-Blackness allows white people to deflect and project their own negative emotions onto a Black subject. Analyzing the movie The Blind Side, she concludes that white peoples’ “need to deny the bewildering manifestations of anti-Blackness […] makes us irrational, and that irrationality is at the heart of white fragility” (98).
Chapter 7 articulates what happens for white people when their racial comfort and sense of safety is threatened and describes the circumstances in which this happens.
The interruption of a white person’s racial comfort can come from a shift in their perception of their “habitus,” a sociology term meaning “a person’s familiar ways of perceiving, interpreting, and responding to the social cues around him or her” (102). When a white person’s racial identity habitus is challenged, they often can only respond defensively. DiAngelo argues that when this kind of challenge causes a disequilibrium for the white person, “white fragility restores equilibrium” (106).
DiAngelo outlines some of the root causes of white fragility, articulating several core ideas about white people and whiteness that build on previous concepts. By exploring how the good/bad binary and anti-Blackness influence white people’s behaviors and actions, for example, DiAngelo lays critical groundwork for her eventual arguments about white fragility.
DiAngelo’s writing style shifts again in these three shorter chapters. While she continues to cite scholarly theories and provide generalized statements on the sociology of whiteness, DiAngelo also weaves in specific examples from her own life and from popular media, like her analysis of The Blind Side. However, these asides are now sparser, and DiAngelo moves through her ideas more rapidly and with less caution than in earlier chapters. By alternating anecdotes, theory, and social commentary, DiAngelo unpacks complex ideas without resting on one modality too heavily.