46 pages • 1 hour read
William ShakespeareA modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.
In the final two acts of the play, the forest outside of Milan emerges as a powerful symbol of both the advantages and restrictions of life in society. Valentine’s banishment from Milan is intended to punish him by not only removing his access to Silvia, but also removing the protection and patronage of life at the Duke’s court. In the first act of the play, Proteus’s father Antonio indicates that the court of Milan is a place where young men can “seek preferment” (1.3.7) and “try their fortune” (1.3.8). By banishing Valentine into the forest, the Duke removes the social advantages that come from being a part of an organized, hierarchical society. Although he is quickly elected King of the Outlaws in the forest, Valentine recognizes that their society is not bound by the same laws as Milan. His demand that the Outlaws “do no outrages on silly women or poor passengers” (4.1.68-69) suggests that he does not fully trust these men to act in a civil way. Even after spending time corralling the Outlaws, Valentine admits that he has “much to do to keep them from uncivil outrages” (5.4.16-17). The Outlaws represent the lawlessness of life outside of the boundaries of society, and suggest that life within the city walls is favorable.
Although he misses Silvia desperately, Valentine does find some comfort in the solitude of the forest: “here I can sit alone, unseen of any, and to the nightingale’s complaining notes tune my distresses and record my woes” (5.4.4-6). For Valentine, the forest is a place where he feels free to fully give into the emotional turmoil of being in love, free from the restrictions of society.
Throughout the play, letters appear as a recurring motif emphasizing the play’s thematic interest in The Restrictions of Courtly Love for Women. Both Julia and Silvia use letters in order to express their romantic desires and assert agency amid the restrictions of a system undergirded by patriarchal hegemony. In Act I, Julia initially rejects Proteus’s love letter because she worries the “wanton lines” (1.2.42) he wrote her will “conspire against my youth” (1.2.43) and reputation. Julia’s fears are explicitly attributed to the rules of courtly love, as she claims that “maids in modesty say ‘no’ to that which they would have the profferer construe ‘Ay’” (1.2.55-56). Julia’s upbringing has taught her to reject men’s advances (in this case, in the form of a letter) even though she loves Proteus and wants to be with him. She later rips the letter into pieces, then kisses each torn piece, further suggesting that she is using the letter to express some sense of agency.
Silvia similarly uses letters to communicate her romantic feelings without risking her reputation. In Act II, she asks Valentine to write a love letter for her to give to another man. When Valentine finishes, she hands him the letter back and tells him to keep it “for your labor” (2.1.113). Like Julia, Silvia cannot actively pursue a man without causing scandal or angering her father. By having Valentine write a letter to himself, Silvia asserts her love for him without overstepping the expectations of noble women in the system of courtly love.
Although their primary role in the play is to provide comic relief, the relationship between Lance and Crab the dog is a powerful symbol of love and loyalty in a play marked by emotional betrayals. Lance’s loyalty toward his beloved dog—despite Crab’s apparent disinterest in his owner—offers a stark contrast to Proteus’s betrayal of both his lover and his friend. In the scene immediately following Proteus and Julia’s tearful goodbye, Lance laments the fact his “cruel-hearted cur” (2.3.7) did not cry when Lance announced he’d be leaving Verona. Lance’s departure from his dog offers a comic twist on the emotional separation of Proteus and Julia. Later in the play, when Proteus sends Lance to Silvia with Crab as a gift, Lance demonstrates valiant loyalty for his pet, taking the blame when Crab urinates on Silvia’s floor. Lance explains that this is not the first time he has risked his own safety and reputation for Crab: “I have sat in the stocks for puddings he hath stolen, otherwise he had been executed” (4.4.23-24). Although Shakespeare crafts the image of an adult being punished for a dog’s crimes to comedic effect, Lance’s willingness to sacrifice himself for Crab demonstrates a complete level of devotion to his pet that far surpasses Proteus’s devotion to Julia.
By William Shakespeare
British Literature
View Collection
Class
View Collection
Class
View Collection
Comedies & Satirical Plays
View Collection
Coming-of-Age Journeys
View Collection
Friendship
View Collection
Laugh-out-Loud Books
View Collection
Loyalty & Betrayal
View Collection
Romance
View Collection
Valentine's Day Reads: The Theme of Love
View Collection