logo

53 pages 1 hour read

Drew Hayden Taylor

The Night Wanderer

Fiction | Novel | YA | Published in 2007

A modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.

Themes

Disconnection and Return to Post-Colonial Home and Culture

Aside from Pierre, each Indigenous character in the novel is depicted in relation to Otter Lake Reserve, demonstrating that for many Indigenous people, reserves are all that is left of their heritage after the myriad horrors of white colonization. Despite this grim reality, the conditions on the reserve cause the characters to experience immense detachment as they seek to improve their situations, even at the cost of losing their most meaningful connections. Within this context, Pierre and Tiffany both epitomize different versions of Indigenous pain and disconnection from their homes, history, and culture, and both must find their own ways of returning to it and reclaiming it after being harmed by the “outside” world.

Home and culture, within the novel, exist in tight relation to one another. Tiffany’s “home” is the Hunter household, but when her relationships grow tense and she loses autonomy and personhood, she seeks belonging in a gradually expanding sphere, wheeling desperately from her friends on the reserve, to Tony, to her mother, and finding nothing but different forms of rejection in each instance. When these encounters systematically fail her, she flees to the woods, and her escape symbolizes a subconscious search for meaning. Her parents and grandmother are all experiencing the direct effects of colonization and taking this pain out on her; this dynamic is demonstrated when her father declares she won’t be permitted to be lazy; his resolution reflects a response to a common stereotype placed on Indigenous people. Likewise, Tiffany’s home and culture provide no comfort, but neither does the outside world, so she is forced to try and find meaning in nature and in death.

Her experience parallels Pierre’s, for he flees his homeland out of a desire for discovery and finds more than he bargained for; the people in France strip him of personhood, and the vampire’s bite ensures that this loss of humanity is permanent. Tiffany explores her own identity by flirting with death, but Pierre’s vampiric nature forces him to reckon with his identity and his death at the same time. While Tiffany’s teenage grievances and Pierre’s centuries of pain and loss cause them to miscommunicate at times, both are ultimately seeking the same thing—a shared history and people on which to relearn identities that have been taken from them. In the end, they bond by understanding their own shared humanity through the lens of time. Their mutual feelings of inhumanity are comforted when they draw closer to their own histories and recognize that they are part of a chain and a culture, not individuals left to fight alone.

Ultimately, the novel presents each Indigenous character’s experience of their home and culture with sympathy and understanding. Some characters respond to their postcolonial, Indigenous existence with grief, others with loneliness, and still others with isolation or avoidance. While the novel does not end with a solid conclusion to the issue, it does provide a ray of light—both literal and metaphorical—through Tiffany and Pierre’s tense understanding of one another. The narrative implies that outside forces, whether white teenagers or vampires, seek to divide, but Indigenous people must recognize the humanity and history that unifies them and then assert their individuality from within that framework.

Juxtaposing Ancient and Modern Lifestyles

Methods of transportation, ways to acquire life necessities, and other technologies recur throughout the novel as different characters explore their environment and find ways to use these elements as signifiers for social status and human connection. For example, Keith uses duck hunting with modern weapons to connect with his friends on the reserve, while Pierre finds spearpoints and arrowheads as he claws for a connection to his old way of life. Granny Ruth desperately tries to find ways to speak in Anishinaabe to help preserve her memories of her culture and her husband, and Tiffany researches carburetors for her class but uses them as an excuse to connect with Tony. In each instance, the modern clashes with the ancient as the characters try to synthesize their own existences, as each character is strung between a long and complex history and yet placed in a modern world with modern expectations and conventions.

Importantly, the novel never presents ancient traditions or modern lifestyles as being inherently superior, but the loss of traditions and connections is treated as a tragedy. For example, the availability of redeye flights allows Pierre to return home, while modern education allows Tiffany and other girls to envision futures for themselves as lawyers or other professionals. Still, complications exist due to the racism threaded throughout the novel. The entrapment of the Europeans initially kept Pierre from returning home and ultimately led to his death and rebirth as a vampire, and the future of any Indigenous teenager on the reserve is complicated by systemic roadblocks that trap people on the reserve and punish them for their dreams. The loss of traditional ways of life—whether of the Anishinaabe language or the experience of pouring syrup on snow—also often comes from external pressures that prevent the Anishinaabe people from choosing how they want to welcome modernity. Ancient cultures are beaten out of existence and then allowed to return in acceptable, exotified ways. Thus, Anishinaabe and Indigenous traditions are commodified and are not permitted to exist organically; for example, Granny Ruth notes that people make money talking about Indigenous customs but “it was mostly those who didn’t really know that much who seemed to get all the attention” (160). These actions strip the traditions of their real use—forming and maintaining relationships with others and with the natural world—and transform them into capitalist, voyeuristic fantasies.

While no character can escape modernity or return to the past, the novel’s integration of both begs for balance and a liberated understanding of history. The narrative acknowledges the positive aspects of modern life but highlights the fact that Indigenous people are permanently marked by the centuries of colonization that brought them there. As a result, their relationships to modernity and to their own past have been damaged. The novel argues that meaning can be found in a genuine and physical understanding of one’s history, for Tiffany needs to hold a spearhead to understand the people that once held it, just as Granny Ruth needs to speak Anishinaabe and Pierre needs to reexperience the physical land he once explored as a child. These experiences cannot be objectified and commodified; they must be real and organic in order to have true meaning. 

European and Indigenous Interpretations of Gothic Horror

While Gothic horror is primarily European in origin, the genre itself is flexible enough to expand to non-European works, particularly those written in the 21st century. Gothic works focus on building an environment of fear and claustrophobia, emphasizing themes like revenge and retribution as well as the tension between monstrosity and humanity. The Night Wanderer is undoubtedly a work of Gothic horror, yet it reimagines specific tropes to explore aspects of Indigenous life in both the past and the present. The novel essentially deconstructs the genre of Gothic horror by situating European qualities within a Canadian reserve, yet the European qualities linger through the vampiric Pierre, who represents a complex threat and yet is essentially a man who has been ruined by the brutality of colonization.

Throughout the novel, Taylor incorporates different elements of traditional Gothic fiction yet presents them as Indigenous realities. For example, the claustrophobic castle of a European Gothic work becomes a lower-middle-class reserve home, and the monstrous vampire becomes a tortured Anishinaabe man desperate to return to the land of his people. Likewise, the requisite isolated landscape is created not by physical distance, but by racism and white rejection of the Otter Lake residents. Traditional Gothic literature had a fascination with the European medieval and sought to weave an eerie undertone of medievality, and Taylor mirrors this dynamic by using the character of Pierre to weave the Anishinaabe past throughout the novel, contrasting it heavily with Tiffany’s modern existence. Additionally, presenting both Tiffany and Pierre as competing protagonists allows Taylor to explore the male and female themes of the Gothic narrative. Tiffany is self-assured yet depressed, just like many Gothic heroines, and she faces complications in her relationships with her parents that mimic many Gothic motifs. Many Gothic novels focused on women trying to articulate their identity in a male-dominated world, often through toxic or outright damaging relationships with men, and this complex pattern is clearly demonstrated in Tiffany’s problematic relationships with Tony, Pierre, and Keith. Meanwhile, Pierre emphasizes the monstrous side of Gothic literature, for he is a man trying to avoid his basest impulses, like many traditional male Gothic protagonists. However, it is also important to note that these impulses are highly unnatural to him, for the curse of vampirism is an affliction of Europe that has been forced upon his unwilling body.

In the end, European Gothic horror often focuses on the ways in which characters’ own personal failings or sins create their own doom. Taylor pointedly reverses this dynamic, for Tiffany and Pierre’s personalities do not ensure their suffering as a traditional Gothic protagonist’s would. Instead, they suffer due to cultural forces that have existed since the onset of Canadian colonialism. Pierre suffers because of a vampire’s choice to transform him, while Tiffany suffers because of the restrictions and myriad cruelties of her society. Fear exists in this novel because the characters do not know how else to respond, not because the characters create their own doom. 

blurred text
blurred text
blurred text
blurred text