45 pages • 1 hour read
Jennifer Zeynab JoukhadarA modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.
Both Nour and Rawiya set off on their adventures in the wake of a father’s death. Both heroines enjoyed close relationships with their fathers, with Nour’s Baba passing on his stories to her and Rawiya’s father teaching her how to use a sling and telling her about the roc. This transfer of paternal power to a daughter would have been unusual in the patriarchal society of each heroine, and it sets up each heroine with expectations that subvert the traditional feminine role.
Though “Rawiya tried to be content with her embroidery and her quiet life with her mother […] she was restless” and “loved to ride up and down the hills and through the olive grove atop her beloved horse, Bauza, and dream of adventures. She wanted to go out and seek her fortune” (7). In an extraordinary manner for a 12th century young woman, Rawiya relates more to her father than her mother. Following his death, she takes on his role as breadwinner so that she can “save her mother from a life of eating barley-flour porridge in their plaster house under the stony face of Jebel Musa” (7). Her father is absent through death, and her brother disappeared at sea—and these absences create the opportunity for Rawiya to assume the previously male power.
Before his death, Nour’s father gifts Rawiya’s story to her as an example of strength and bravery. Nour initially associates Rawiya with her father when she tries to tell the tale in his words exactly. However, the clue in the tale’s initial words that “everybody knows the story of Rawiya […] they just don’t know they know it,” encourages Nour to make the story her own (6). Hereafter, as Joukhadar interweaves the two heroines’ tales, Rawiya’s narrative shapes Nour’s interpretation of her own life, rather than being a souvenir of her father’s presence.
Both heroines replace the initial lost patriarch with another, as Rawiya becomes al-Idrisi’s apprentice and Nour follows her mother back to Syria so their family can be reunited with Abu Sayeed. Al-Idrisi and Abu Sayeed are sages who share their wisdom, educating the heroines and encouraging them to trust their instinct. Inevitably, as is common to many hero’s journey narratives, both heroines lose their second patriarchs and must stake out on their own. While Rawiya does not lose al-Idrisi to death, she increasingly proves a better warrior than he was, and has to rely upon her own instincts, and on what her father has taught her, to develop military strategy. Nour’s loss of Abu Sayeed to drowning is a more tragic initiation of independence. With the loss of Abu Sayeed, who filled the paternal role of helping her discover the wonders of the world, she must rely on herself and her more elusive, map-making mother.
While Nour’s father and Abu Sayeed impart their lessons more didactically, Nour’s mother is more enigmatic. As a woman navigating a terrain run by dangerous men, Nour’s mother is conscious that her daughters would be more at risk if others found out where they were going. She therefore disguises the destinations on her map with a code that corresponds to Nour’s synesthesia. Here, the implication is that the feminine route to safety must be one of secrecy and dissimulation. When Nour succeeds in the mission her mother gives her—a mission that only she can fulfill—she creates her own adventure story that has been informed by her own abilities rather than those of patriarchs. Using their own strategies to succeed, the heroines stand out as the authors of their own adventure stories.
In Rawiya’s apprenticeship initiation, al-Idrisi asks her the following question: “what is the most important place on a map?” (11). After toying with the idea that the traveler’s current location or home could be most important, Rawiya eventually concludes that “the most important places on a map are the places you’ve never been” (12). The idea of unexplored places–both literal and metaphorical–forms a key thread in both heroines’ stories. On a literal level, both heroines traverse unknown territories; however, on a metaphorical level, they must grow personally and explore the unknown terrain of their own consciousness.
As she tells Rawiya’s story to herself, Nour draws strength from the fact that Rawiya traverses the same territories and overcomes her opponents with her mission intact. However, while storytelling occupies Nour’s troubled mind and grounds her experiences in a more optimistic framework, she realizes some disparities between her journey and Rawiya’s in the mythic era of the roc. For example, when Nour must sacrifice her beloved curls to avert sexual assault, she literally shuts her eyes to reality and tells herself “I’m not Rawiya. This isn’t an adventure” and lets a “yellow wail bubble […] out of me” (139). Here, Nour loathes her resemblance to her boyish heroine, as the grief of lost femininity further compounds what she has already endured.
Homecoming is in tension with adventure, and at times the two are antithetical. While both heroines end up in Ceuta and intend to settle there, they each experience a different type of homecoming. Rawiya returns to Ceuta on her beloved horse and ends up in her birthplace and her maternal home. She joyfully reunites with her mother and brother, but also expands her home to include Khaldun and al-Idrisi. Additionally, her family role changes to that of provider using her hard-won fortune. Here, Joukhadar shows that while homecoming may be essential to adventure, home is defined not only by location but by one’s inner strengths.
While Nour also returns to a storied home, it is a home she has never visited. Both Nour’s more tangible homes, Manhattan and Homs, are inaccessible. She must learn to make her home wherever her relatives can gather safely. Like Rawiya, Nour’s sense of home expands to new people, including Yusuf and Uncle Ma’mun. Her time in the desert with the Amazigh nomads taught her “the land where your parents were born will always be in you” as “borders are nothing to words and blood” (298). Indeed, Nour eventually discovers that reading and understanding Arabic comes more easily to her, and her adventures which led her away from Syria paradoxically bring her closer to home.
Both Rawiya and Nour are women in an era of battles started by men, a position with unique obstacles. Rawiya takes it for granted that she lives in a patriarchal society where she faces discrimination as an openly female adventurer, and her knowledge of her disempowered situation leads her to dress herself as a boy from the outset of her expedition. Nour, in contrast, grew up in the more egalitarian Manhattan amongst strong female role models, and she struggles with the idea that her femininity makes her more vulnerable. She disputes that shorn curls and a boyish appearance will keep her safe, until she sees firsthand her sister Huda’s attempted rape. She sees how one of Huda’s assailants “grabs at the pleats of Huda’s long skirt, lifting them up over the tongues of her sneakers, over her brown calves,” while the other one “pushes her skirt up over her knees” (162). There is an emphasis on Huda’s skirt, which is worn modestly long in line with the expectations of her Muslim faith. The skirt symbolizes her femininity, and it is partly her femininity to which the assailants were drawn.
Nour knows that the boys who “wear strange smirks, their eyes half-lidded” attack Huda because they see her as temptation that chances to cross their path, and they will take advantage of her because they are physically stronger (162). The girls are helpless against the boys’ superior physical strength, and Nour is powerless to stop the attack. Nour contemplates that an attempted rape can “cost you as much” as a completed rape, as “the real wound is the moment you understand that you can do nothing.” She watches Huda “tug […] the pleats of her skirt down, pressing the folds flat, like it’s all she can do not to scream” (166). The idea of a trapped scream occurs elsewhere in the novel, echoing the trauma endured by female refugees.
While the girls’ self-defense is futile, Abu Sayeed intervenes. A restored sense of safety is fleeting, however, given Abu Sayeed’s imminent death. Nour must face the challenge of traveling without male protection when her mother sends her and Zahra out on their own.
In the wake of Huda’s attack, Nour’s previously positive relationship with men deteriorates to a deep suspicion. She immediately traces a comparison between Yusuf and an assailant, noticing his hair is cut in the same style and that “his gray tee shirt is stained with sweat, smelling like the boy who pulled up Huda’s skirt” (166). When Yusuf talks to Nour alone on the boat and gifts her his penknife, Nour adopts a nuanced view of the world, including both caution and the allowance for men to show their goodness. At the end of the novel, in both Rawiya’s and Nour’s arrival at Ceuta, both men and women have important and equal roles to play in the restructuring of peacetime structures. Joukhadar makes an argument for participation according to aptitude and personality rather than traditional gender roles.
Action & Adventure
View Collection
American Literature
View Collection
Books that Feature the Theme of...
View Collection
Coming-of-Age Journeys
View Collection
Grief
View Collection
Immigrants & Refugees
View Collection
Memorial Day Reads
View Collection
Middle Eastern Literature
View Collection
Military Reads
View Collection