53 pages • 1 hour read
Marjan KamaliA modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.
The novel is shaped by the complex friendship between the two protagonists, Ellie and Homa. Though their relationship goes through phases of closeness and separation, both physically and emotionally, their love for each other endures. These bonds suggest that friendship can be as important, and enduring, as the bonds of family or marriage.
The powerful friendship between Ellie and Homa seems almost predestined, with Homa appearing like an answer to Ellie’s prayer for family and companionship. Their bond is cemented not only through the shared experience of school and childhood games but also by how their contrasting lives complement one another. Ellie provides a balance to Homa’s high spirits and a friendly rival to Homa’s competitive spirit. Homa enriches Ellie’s life by enfolding Ellie into her family, providing a sense of belonging Ellie longs for. The nurturing power of their friendship is expressed through Ellie’s joy at learning to cook and the simple magic she perceives in chopping an onion: Friendship is an alchemy that transforms Ellie, just as food is transformed through cooking.
Ellie, unlike Homa, doesn’t initially understand the lasting power of young adult friendships. She sees her relationship with Homa as something that must fade as they leave childhood. As a teenager, she thinks, “Our bond should have been impossible to fray and then disintegrate. But as time took us each in a different direction, it was astonishingly simple for our connection to dissolve” (66). This early separation foreshadows their later estrangement—what Ellie calls ghaar—which continues when Ellie moves to the US. Both separations are easier for Homa to move past, as she doesn’t believe that friendships dissolve. She continues to think of Ellie as her close friend, even when Ellie moves out of their Tehran neighborhood, and she seeks to reunite by joining Ellie’s school. She speaks of Ellie as a dear friend throughout her adulthood, to the point that Bahar feels she knows Ellie already. The pink notebook, the gift from Ellie, which Homa keeps and eventually returns filled with her mother’s recipes, represents Homa’s enduring affection. Through the notebook, Homa shows Ellie that real friendship can persist despite obstacles and separation.
Homa demonstrates that loyalty is key to bonds of friendship. Homa remains loyal to the idea of their friendship even when they are separated, and her wish to protect Ellie from harm is the reason she resists interrogation and avoids contact later, after she is out of prison. Ellie shows loyalty in her own fashion, particularly in the teapot she purchases because it reminds her of their early friendship, but Ellie’s feelings are complicated by guilt in a way that Homa’s aren’t. Homa demonstrates that the choice to sacrifice oneself can show the depth of friendship. While the presumed friendship between the US and Iran is broken by the hostage crisis, Ellie demonstrates that she has learned this lesson about loyalty and friendship through her choice to take in Bahar. Ellie again shows her loyalty by hosting Leily’s 18th birthday party, and she speaks of Homa with admiration, even wearing the necklace Homa gave her as a childhood gift well into her later years.
The theme of guilt and its burdens is introduced early in the novel and entwined with the theme of friendship, suggesting the shadow side that can emerge from closeness with another person. The destructive power of envy, signified by the evil eye, is expressed as a real force, something to fear. However, like the theme of friendship, Homa’s example proves the power of forgiveness and redemption to heal the wounds of these harmful emotions and reknit more productive, nurturing bonds.
Ellie thinks of jealousy as the weak part of her nature, her chief character flaw, and it arises most conspicuously because of her closeness with Homa. Ellie dislikes being an only child and feels burdened by her mother’s complaints and grief after losing her father, so the affection and warmth of Homa’s family fill her with longing. She later confesses guilt for the way she imagined becoming a part of the family. Ellie’s mother, always alert to the way she is perceived by others, fosters this same self-consciousness in Ellie, and Ellie later wonders if her envy worked like the evil eye, destroying Homa’s family first with the imprisonment of her father and later by separating Homa and Bahar. She believes that jealousy is a power that could destroy even the strongest friendship.
This is further demonstrated through Ellie’s inadvertent betrayal, when jealousy over Homa’s competence, fear that Homa has attracted Mehrdad, and insecurity over her own seeming lack of maturity lead Ellie into the discussion with the colonel where, in thinking she is bragging about Homa’s accomplishments, she instead exposes her to the secret police. Ellie’s jealousy separates them physically when Homa is seized, and Ellie’s guilt makes her feel responsible for Homa not wanting to see her.
Ellie defeats her sense of jealousy with maturity, but it is revisited in her response to learning she will not bear a biological child. She doesn’t envy her friends their enjoyment of their children, but guilt over what happened to Homa continues to burden her. Mehrdad counsels her not to blame herself for Homa’s arrest or the downfall of Homa’s family. Nevertheless, feeling that she failed her friend remains a significant character obstacle for Ellie. When she takes in Homa’s daughter, it doesn’t feel like an act of redemption to her but a duty she owes Homa because of her guilt. Ellie can’t forgive herself until Homa knows the truth, and real redemption happens when Ellie is able to experience Homa’s uncomplicated, unconditional forgiveness. The actions of the novel suggest that, while envy and guilt can be powerful, friendship and love are stronger.
The influence of mothers is subtly but powerfully present in the text, serving as a guiding force in shaping the lives of the protagonists. This theme speaks to women’s power, their sacrifices, and the qualities that define the shir zan, or lion women, as protectors and nurturers.
In the example of Ellie’s parent, the influence of mothers is at first shown through its negative aspects, as Ellie feels burdened by her mother’s complaints, grief, loneliness, and the pride that makes her feel superior to the residents of downtown Tehran, who have a less-fortunate socioeconomic situation than Ellie prefers. The disappointment she feels in her own mother makes the nurturing abilities of Monir, Homa’s mother, more attractive to Ellie; she believes that love ought to manifest in expressions of affection and playfulness, interest and support, and guidance, such as teaching a daughter how to cook. Ellie sees her own mother’s choice to marry Massoud as manipulative and somewhat heartless, though she later perceives real affection between them. She recognizes her mother’s self-interest but still feels wounded by it. To Ellie, her mother’s emotional reaction to the marriage request from Mehrdad and his family seems manipulative and staged rather than sincere.
It is only later, when they talk at Bloomingdale’s, that Ellie learns that her mother’s motivations were always to do what she felt was in Ellie’s best interests. Ellie realizes, “She had suffered in ways she had hidden from me for my entire life so far. She did, in her own way, love me more than anything” (253). This is the mark of mothers, expressed in Monir’s protectiveness of Homa while she is in prison and after, and likewise expressed in Homa’s need to heal from her trauma so she can care for Bahar. Homa demonstrates how sacrifice often goes hand in hand with protectiveness when she realizes it is best for Bahar to go to the US. Though she is separated from her daughter for years, Homa never regrets the choice to give Bahar better circumstances, including a safe home, opportunities for education, the ability to pursue a career, and personal freedoms.
Ellie contributes to this picture of protective motherhood with her own version of mothering Bahar, first expressed by her selection of a Snoopy toothbrush, knowing of Bahar’s childhood affection for the cartoon character. Ellie is often taken to be Bahar’s mother, suggesting that her concern and affection are evident. Part of Ellie’s care for Bahar and Leily is educating them on their heritage as shir zan, as Homa wishes for her daughter’s future to involve the larger fight for rights and opportunities for Iranian women.
Books on Justice & Injustice
View Collection
Books that Feature the Theme of...
View Collection
Class
View Collection
Class
View Collection
Coming-of-Age Journeys
View Collection
Feminist Reads
View Collection
Forgiveness
View Collection
Guilt
View Collection
Memory
View Collection
Mothers
View Collection
War
View Collection