64 pages • 2 hours read
Lisa JewellA modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.
The Bird family home symbolizes the family’s trauma, and its disarray and stifling atmosphere represent the family’s inability to move on from tragedy. Lorelei cultivates this cluttered home environment as a coping mechanism for her childhood trauma, but this environment makes her family members feel trapped, and they long to escape. Lorelei is the only one happy to stay where she is. She can’t understand the appeal of going abroad, and when Colin mentions spending Easter in Greece, it sends her into a spiral of despair. She wants to keep her children trapped in their childhoods, as shown by her insistence on keeping a craft box even though their interests have changed. The house’s claustrophobic aspect is clear in Meg’s descriptions of it: “She saw herself squeezing through smaller and smaller apertures, into deeper and deeper corners of the house until she was squashed into a ball and unable to turn around” (26). In trying to preserve good memories and protect herself, Lorelei inadvertently cut herself off from the rest of the world, an example of how coping mechanisms can backfire and render one more isolated.
Smothered by Lorelei’s attempts to keep them young and close, each Bird child fantasizes about escape. During the first Easter Sunday mentioned in the book, Meg feels too old to sit at the children’s table and too young to be at the adult table. She wants to break through her mother’s attempts at keeping her in a permanent childhood, envisioning it as “a glorious explosion of glass shards, as she slammed her fists through the invisible walls around her. She imagined fresh air and bright light and dizzying amounts of space” (20). When she finally escapes to London, she creates the life she envisions, but it is also a kind of prison. She has to keep her place supremely clean and tidy, meaning it is difficult for her family to relax. Meg’s escape, like Lorelei’s, is ineffectual because she does not address the root of her anxiety; as she connects with her daughter and reconciles with her siblings, she feels more at peace, indicating that community is more healing than escape.
This is reinforced by the other family members as well. When Rory meets Kayleigh, he realizes that he has been “set in aspic” and “pickled in grief” since his brother died (97). Comparing himself to preserved foods, the confines of his mother’s home make him feel less human. When he travels abroad, he is able to go “somewhere that Rhys had never been,” but he finds that he cannot escape “the ghosts” of his trauma. Like Meg, the promise of escape falls short and he is still stuck, leaving Kayleigh and their child because he still feels like he’s 16. Another escape attempt brings him to Thailand, and he turns to Owen as a brother/father figure. However, Owen cannot provide the community and stability that Rory needs, and he betrays him to save himself. Ironically, imprisonment gives Rory the space to examine his emotions and motives; he believes it is retribution for not looking after his brother properly and casting aside Kayleigh and Tia. Being isolated from those he cares about motivates him to seek out his family after he’s released, setting the groundwork for him to reconcile with his siblings and truly begin healing. Similarly, Colin thinks he’ll find himself by escaping Lorelei, but his new life doesn’t truly begin until he connects with Kayleigh and becomes a father to Tia.
Beth is the last to escape from home, and like Rory, it takes another person for this to happen. She refers to Jason as “a life-raft” (220), and he allows her to imagine a different future for herself. In her mother’s house, “[s]he was a prisoner […] entirely of her own making” (220). Without her own identity, she was behaving self-destructively, adopting some of Lorelei’s hoarding habits and sleeping with Meg’s husband. Like her siblings, though, moving to the other side of the world does not bring her the sense of freedom she was searching for. She feels like an actor on a stage; she created a world that wasn’t real, which became like a prison for her.
It is only after Lorelei’s death and clearing out the house’s prison-like environment that the family can come together and be healed by that reunion. Purged of its items and secrets, the ghosts are laid to rest, and the family can start fresh. The family’s transition is represented by Beth, her new baby, and Rory living in the house and making it their own. They have all escaped but now feel free to come and go as they please.
Content Warning: This section includes the possibly triggering topic of incest and sexual abuse.
Lorelei has always struggled to manage her feelings, but Jim’s insights into her complicated family situation help her see the ties between the past and the present. What happened to her mother affected her, and the way that she was brought up affects her family. She loves her children but couldn’t nurture them, because she wasn’t nurtured as a child. Lorelei learns that there are “threads that connected it all together” and these are “vaguely incestuous” (407): Her mother was raped by a man who then went on to sexually abuse her, Beth has an affair with her sister’s partner, and Colin lives with Kayleigh and Tia, who is his grandchild but also calls him Papa. Most significantly, Rhys spies on his sister and tries to kiss his mother. Without addressing the root of her childhood trauma, Lorelei has watched these harmful behaviors repeat in her family, which are alternately presented sympathetically and by Meg as “one disgusting lurid thing after another” (226).
As trauma distorts relationships, the relatives start to lose touch with each other and memories are likewise contorted. Instead of viewing her family members as whole people with good and bad traits, they become negative caricatures. Where the Bird children remember Lorelei “when she was bustling and mad and full of energy and rainbows,” Molly remembers her as “being kind of…weird” (304). Colin is morphed from patient and passive into “a sleazy old man,” and Rory’s popularity and pleasantness are cast aside for an image of a “pathetic drug dealer” (305). This is a different coping mechanism than Lorelei’s tendency to view everything as sunshine and rainbows, but this tactic likewise prevents healing. By reducing the family members to their worst actions and cultural stereotypes, the root causes of their behaviors are never addressed. Above all, each Bird is lonely and looking for connection; when they can’t find it in each other, they search for it elsewhere, sometimes in the wrong places. Without reconciling honestly and openly, they seem doomed to repeat the same maladaptive behaviors.
With time and forgiveness, though, the family starts to come together again, showing how family bonds are resilient and not easily broken. Various secrets are uncovered, allowing for greater communication between them. Molly becomes more accepting of Colin and Kayleigh’s relationship, saying “it’s life.” Likewise, Meg forgives her sister’s affair, and her relationship with Bill recovers. With past wounds healing, the happier aspects of family ties can emerge. Meg and Beth still have the “Bird” face, Molly looks like her uncle, and Beth’s daughter is given the middle name of Lorelei’s stillborn sister. Breaking generational traumas is represented in how the younger cousins—Stanley, Alfie, and Tia—are happy to play together. The family also expands to incorporate others, including Kayleigh and Tia, Vicky’s daughters Maddy and Sophie, and Jim, highlighting the value of other community members in the healing process.
One of Lisa Jewell’s literary techniques is the use of different viewpoints and perspectives, either to give a range of opinions on a situation or to provide her characters with opportunities for realization. The book has an omniscient narrator, but most sections are split between the viewpoints of several characters. Lorelei’s emails to Jim are all in the first person, with his voice only being heard at the end of the book after her funeral. This one-sided correspondence allows the reader into Lorelei’s head but also creates a sense of mystery as she hints at family secrets. It also acts as a countdown to her own death, as she prepares to take the journey to meet Jim that the reader knows she won’t complete. Lorelei is characterized by her refusal to listen to anyone who challenges the world she’s created for herself, but her relationship with Jim offers a new perspective for her. With his help, she starts to face the reality she keeps hidden from herself and others. As an outsider, he is able to take an objective view, allowing her to make connections between the past and the present and understand why she reacts in the way she does. With this, she makes her first steps toward progress and healing.
Others go through this process as well. Rory doesn’t see his mother’s hoarding as a problem until Kayleigh comments on how the “place is pure chaos” (86). Faced with this reality, “[t]he delicate, tissue-thin layers of his own lack of objectivity were being ripped apart” (86), motivating him to break out of his sense of paralysis and start a new life with Kayleigh. Beth also sees this when she witnesses Vicky and Colin arguing with Lorelai about Rhys’s old towel and suddenly realizes how filthy everything has become. Beth had adapted to the situation, but she now notices how her messy room contrasts with her desk at work, where everything is neatly organized. This flash of clarity pushes her to finally leave home.
When Colin visits Rory in Thailand, Rory thinks it’s odd to see Owen “suddenly through someone else’s eyes. It was discomfiting and strangely sad” (240). But where he thinks his father will be impressed, Colin pronounces him a “buffoon” and Rory’s lifestyle as shallow and meaningless. This clarity is too little too late for Rory as it doesn’t prevent him from being betrayed by Owen and arrested. Being in prison and then on a Buddhist retreat, however, give him a new perspective on life and people. When he returns for his mother’s funeral, everyone looks different, older, and larger. Growing up, Rory laughed affectionately at his mother’s ways, but his time in poverty-stricken countries makes him see the family house as obscene: “What his mother had done here, as poor people scavenged for food in landfill, as parents watched their children die, as disease wiped out villages and waterholes dried up, it subverted everything” (389). The most traveled of them all, he’s achieved a wider perspective.
All these new perspectives blend when the family comes together after Lorelei’s death, and the siblings even gain new understandings about Lorelei’s hoarding. They realize some of the items she kept were genuinely valuable or nostalgic, building more compassion for her. In the end, the family finally reaches the state of harmony that Lorelei sought, in part because they left home and developed greater insight about themselves and the world.
By Lisa Jewell