logo

53 pages 1 hour read

Pam Muñoz Ryan, Illustr. Peter Sis

The Dreamer

Fiction | Novel | Middle Grade | Published in 2008

A modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.

Chapters 10-12Chapter Summaries & Analyses

Chapter 10 Summary: “Love”

Neftalí is now 11 years old and still the skinniest and weakest boy in his class. He is approached by Guillermo, a bully, who wants help writing a love letter to the girl he likes. Guillermo knows Neftalí is good with words, so he tells him to write the kinds of things girls want to hear, but sign Guillermo’s name to it. It’s for Blanca, the same girl Neftalí likes. He knows if he doesn’t write the letter, or if it fails to impress Blanca, Guillermo will make his life miserable.

Having never written a love letter, Neftalí reads the letters in Mamadre’s trunk for inspiration. They’re written by someone named Enrique, addressed to a Maria, and full of beautiful, memorable sentiments. Neftalí hasn’t experienced the kind of love in Enrique’s letters, but he does love Laurita, Uncle Orlando, Rodolfo, and most of all, Mamadre. He practices by writing all the words that express his affection and gratitude for her. Soon, sentences form in his mind that demand to be written.

The letter Neftalí gives to Guillermo is based on Neftalí’s own feelings for Blanca. After school on the day she receives it from Guillermo, Blanca approaches Neftalí. She says she can tell he wrote it because, “Guillermo can barely put two words together,” adding, “But you are capable of such artistry” (255). Neftalí admits it by nodding, but her presence makes him so nervous he can’t speak or look her in the eye. Blanca gives Neftalí a quince in thanks. After that, he writes a letter to her each week and gives it to her through Guillermo, who doesn’t realize she knows the truth. Each week he receives her thanks—in the form of a quince—in a wordless exchange.

After five weeks, Neftalí learns Blanca’s family has to move far away due to a relative’s sudden illness. He imagines stopping Blanca on the train platform as she’s about to leave and giving her his heart-shaped rock. She kisses him and they promise to write to each other weekly and forever. In reality, Neftalí has Laurita give Blanca the rock at the train station while he hides inside, watching her departure from his window.

Chapter 10 is preceded by a double-page illustration of a quill pen with wings. The wings contain the image of a person walking along a path that winds through mountains and fields. The fourth stanza of Pam Muñoz Ryan’s poem, “I Am Poetry,” accompanies the illustration. Chapter 10’s only full-page illustration shows a spider’s web on the outline of a human head, with a heart at the web’s center. The caption asks, “Who spins the elaborate web that entraps the timid spirit?” (266-67).

Chapter 11 Summary: “Passion”

Neftalí has just returned home from his third summer in Puerto Saavedra. He’s 13 years old and taller than Rodolfo now, but still too skinny in his father’s eyes. He asks Uncle Orlando to let him work at the newspaper. Orlando agrees but says only with his father’s permission. He’ll join the Reyes family for dinner to try to convince Father. In the meantime, Neftalí asks Orlando to review an essay he wrote for a school competition.

Rodolfo also joins the family for dinner that night on a visit home from his work in Santiago. Father has many men from town as dinner guests too. Neftalí is eager to see his brother, but Rodolfo spends the evening talking to other businesspeople. When Uncle Orlando arrives, he relays the news that another Mapuche man has been murdered for refusing to leave his land. He accuses Father’s guests of complicity, saying, “To some of you that is not news because you were involved, even indirectly, with such inhumane actions” (281). Orlando announces a new group has formed to speak on behalf of the Mapuche at town meetings.

Orlando then tells everyone he’s going to read them an article that will be published in his paper the next day. As he reads, Neftalí recognizes his essay about “the importance of following dreams and staying determined” (283). It receives a great deal of applause, after which Orlando reveals it was written by Neftalí and asks Father to let Neftalí work for him. He presents it as a way to help him afford university. Father says no and that it would be a distraction from studying. Rodolfo helps plead Neftalí’s case, saying he gets the best grades in school and the job will help him learn business skills. He knows Father has said many times, “There is always a future in business” (289). These arguments, along with Mamadre’s delicious dessert delivered to the table at just the right moment, convince Father to give his permission.

In two months working for the newspaper, Neftalí masters the printing press. He notices while he works that Orlando has started behaving oddly, secretively. One night, the Mapuche advocacy group meets in secret at the newspaper office to plan a protest. Neftalí helps keep watch for developers. They mustn’t know about the protest, Orlando says—they’ve killed so many already.

Late in the night after the meeting concludes, the newspaper office is set on fire. Most of the town gathers in the street in panic. Neftalí joins the brigade passing buckets of water to put out the fire, but the office is destroyed by the time the flames are quelled. Orlando tells Neftalí the developers are trying to silence him. He vows to never give up speaking out for what’s right. Neftalí makes the same vow.

Chapter 11’s only full-page illustration depicts the shape of a bird formed by illegible words, rising from a flame. Its caption asks, “Is fire born of words? Or are words born of fire?” (310-11).

Chapter 12 Summary: “Fire”

Three years have passed since the fire that burned down Uncle Orlando’s newspaper office. Neftalí tells his sister that Orlando, working in another town, has just printed the first issue of his new paper. Neftalí has his own news as well: He’s been made a correspondent for Claridad, the student magazine at Santiago University, where Neftalí will be going in the fall. Claridad printed an article he wrote about the Mapuche, and they want him to write more.

A few days later, a local shopkeeper brings Father a copy of the magazine, which mistakenly says Neftalí is enrolling in the university to become a poet. Outraged, Father calls Neftalí an embarrassment and sets fire to all his notebooks. Neftalí feels devastated, defeated, but under the pile of ashes that were once his thoughts and feelings, his dreams and affections, he finds a glowing ember.

Several months later, Neftalí learns that a poet he greatly admired, Rojas, was arrested during a student protest and died in prison. Neftalí is filled with an urgent desire to respond, to fight back. He adopts a pen name so he can continue writing without incurring his father’s wrath or causing harm to his family. Combining the names of a Czech writer and an Italian poet, he lands on “Pablo Neruda” as his pseudonym. Then, he packs his things, says goodbye to his family, and leaves for Santiago University.

In Santiago, Neftalí follows the irresistible call of poetry. No matter his circumstances, he writes. Eventually, his words travel the world, inspiring people with the power of his dreams.

Chapter 12’s first full-page illustration shows a notebook with a picture of a boy on the pages and one corner engulfed in flame. The next illustration is of a large body of water, with hills in the background and clouds in the sky. Books are piled on one of the clouds. The caption asks, “Where is the heaven of lost stories?” (330-31). Another illustration depicts an egg overlaid by the image of a person looking at a smaller egg. The top of the larger egg is cracked, and wings are emerging. The caption asks, “Does a metamorphosis begin from the outside in? Or from the inside out?” (337). On Pages 346-351, a progression of images shows a book gradually becoming part bird and taking flight. The chapter’s final illustration shows a shadowy figure in a hat and cloak, with its legs replaced by a quill pen.

Chapters 10-12 Analysis

While previous chapter groupings were linked by elements of nature, the final three chapters of The Dreamer revolve around internal characteristics, including emotions and personal values. The narrative arc reaches its climax when Orlando’s newspaper office is destroyed by fire. Brief descriptions of Neftalí’s life and writing in Santiago bring the story of Neftalí’s childhood to its resolution, foreshadowing his future impact and legacy as he confronts issues of Inspiration, Influence, and Identity and defiantly chooses his own path.

Foreshadowing is used earlier in Chapter 12. After Father burns Neftalí’s notebooks, a tiny ember glows under the pile of ash. This connection to the metaphoric ember under the ash of Orlando’s burned office hints that Neftalí won’t give up writing, that he won’t be silenced by such acts. The two parallel fire scenes establish an important conflict in the story: truth versus forced silence. This conflict is manifested first as the struggle of Uncle Orlando’s newspaper—and the Mapuche advocacy group—against the developers. Later it is manifested through the government’s efforts to silence writers, poets, and student protesters.

Scenes of magical realism embodying Neftalí’s imagination develop themes about identity and The Power of Words. Of Neftalí’s newly-chosen pseudonym, the author writes, “The names slid off the paper, marched across the room, and draped themselves on the hook on the back of the bedroom door, becoming a suit of fine clothing […] The name was not only a perfect solution, it was a perfect fit” (335). Neftalí must use this pseudonym to protect his identity like a suit protects a body. He might only use the name until he fully discovers who he is; until he becomes “lost enough to find himself” (336), or finding himself will mean incorporating the new name into his identity as he defines and creates it.

Neftalí’s response to Orlando’s inspiring proclamation following the newspaper office fire demonstrates The Power of Words. Neftalí captures his sentiments on paper that night. His words “wriggled off the page and escaped from the drawer. The letters stacked themselves, one on top of the other. Their towers reached higher and higher until they stood majestic and tall, surrounding Neftalí in a city of promise” (299). This scene symbolizes how self-expression gives Neftalí strength. His fear gnaws at the tower’s foundations and topples them, illustrating an internal conflict between expression and fear.

Guillermo’s character, apart from being a literal bully, serves as a symbol of those who abuse their power, using fear and intimidation to control and silence their opposition. He represents the childhood version of the opponents Neftalí will face later, like murderous developers and an oppressive government. Blanca’s character, as a love interest, demonstrates the intensity of Neftalí’s shyness, illustrating what barriers he must overcome to experience the friendship and human connection he longs for.

As Neftalí matures, he gains insight into the complexity of his father’s character. Just before leaving home, he looks into his father’s eyes and wonders, “Who was inside? Someone mean and hateful? Or someone so controlled by his own past that he dared not allow anyone he loved to control their own future?” (339-40). Seeing his complicated relationship with his father from this perspective frees Neftalí from the metaphoric chains of his father’s criticisms. Had he taken his father’s treatment personally, resentment might have consumed him. His father’s insults would have limited him. This parting scene offers a sort of resolution to the narrative conflict between Neftalí and his father. Though the relationship doesn’t become an ideal one, Neftalí learns to free himself from its restrictive hold.

A pivotal point in Neftalí’s character arc occurs in the aftermath of the fire that burned Orlando’s newspaper office. When his uncle says the developers will never silence his pen, Neftalí takes Orlando’s hand and says, “Nor will they silence mine” (309). He’s decided not to let fear win against the expression of truth.

The conflicts between truth and censorship and between expression and fear culminate in a thematic message about resistance and fighting for what’s right. Uncle Orlando inspires Neftalí to do so, telling him, “there is always something that can be done […] they can never make me surrender my true feelings. I will wait. And then I will start again” (306). He instills in Neftalí a spirit of resilience and self-sacrifice. In the face of opposition that might have exhausted Orlando and made him despair, Neftalí sees righteousness and a resolve to keep fighting. He witnesses in Orlando the type of man he wants to be—a moment that shapes his future political activism.

Neftalí’s identity continues to take shape in these chapters. After the climactic fire, Neftalí hopes he can be strong when the time comes but isn’t convinced. The narrative’s falling action and resolution are imbued with a tone of authorial confidence in Neftalí’s strength, even if he lacks confidence in himself. When he is out of his father’s household and free to make his own choices, Neftalí heeds the call of poetry, showing he has the strength to persevere in the pursuit of his dreams. The thematic exploration of Inspiration, Influence, and Identity culminates in the message that identity can be built and changed over time as an individual grows, and while it is influenced by those who inspire or traumatize, identity is ultimately self-defined.

blurred text
blurred text
blurred text
blurred text