logo

70 pages 2 hours read

William Kent Krueger

Ordinary Grace

Fiction | Novel | Adult | Published in 2013

A modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.

Chapters 15-18Chapter Summaries & Analyses

Chapter 15 Summary

It’s almost the Fourth of July, and Ruth and Ariel leave the Drum household to attend the final rehearsal for the Independence Day celebration in New Bremen’s Luther Park. Father Peter, a friend of Nathan’s who is a Catholic priest, has spent the afternoon playing tennis with Nathan and stays at the Drum house after dinner. Father Peter communicates concerns he’s heard from the community about the fact that Ruth, a minister’s wife, both drinks and smokes cigarettes, adding that Ruth was wild in her youth. He goes on to say that Ruth “shuns the activities of the WSCS,” or Women’s Society of Christian Service (131). Nathan counters by saying she spends her time focused on the church’s music programs.

Later that evening, Frank heads toward the Heights with Jake in tow. Jake urges Frank to tell Gus about the incident with Engdahl, and also tells Frank that he should apologize to Engdahl for pushing him into the water. Frank tells Jake not to worry. Here, Krueger, through Frank, establishes Engdahl as a possible culprit for the impending murder of Ariel. This segues into Frank’s questioning of Ariel’s motives for wanting to remain in New Bremen: “In the hours since I’d left the quarry I’d come to realize that not only was [Ariel] in love with Karl Brandt but she’d probably been sleeping with him as well” (133). “As if conjured by the devil of [Frank’s] thinking,” Karl Brandt then arrives on the scene in his red Triumph sports car (133).

Karl drives Frank and Jake to the town’s tiny college, where he plans to pick up Ariel. The three take a circuitous route so Karl can show off the speed of the car, with Frank “marveling at the ease of his life and at the same time feeling the slow invasion of resentment that had never been there before” (134).

In the college auditorium, Frank and Jake come across Ariel, Ruth and Emil Brandt. Ariel leaves with Karl. Ruth tells her sons to head home. Frank eavesdrops on an intimate conversation between Ruth and Emil, in which Emil calls Nathan Drum lucky to be married to Ruth. Emil confesses to Ruth, “‘I have moments of such darkness…[s]uch darkness you can’t imagine’” (136).

At home, in their shared bedroom, Jake asks Frank what “skag” means and the two have a conversation about girls and kissing and what constitutes loose morals. 

Chapter 16 Summary

The Fourth of July arrives. Ruth sends Frank to Emil Brandt’s house and Jake to the house of the editor of the local paper. Frank arrives to the Brandt’s house to find neither Ariel nor Emil at home. He knocks then enters the residence, finding Lise Brandt, in a back bedroom, standing naked and ironing clothes: “The room was a glory of flowers cut from her garden…[h]er back was to me…I watched the strong muscles of her shoulders and back and buttocks tense and release and every part of her body seemed alive in itself and not just an element of some larger configuration of flesh” (142). Frank sneaks back out of the house and waits on the porch steps. Lise comes out twenty minutes later; Frank asks her where Ariel is, and Lise says that she doesn’t know.

Later, at lunch, Ariel tells her family that she had been out driving Emil around, for inspiration. Emil’s mood has improved, and “he was more inspired than he’d been in years” (143). Ruth and Ariel discuss Emil further, with Ruth saying that, “‘[Emil’s] always been a wounded man. He’s always been…too misunderstood, too little appreciated, too bound by our provincialism here, too everything that did not advance the wants, needs and desires of his own often selfish heart’” (144).

Ariel tells Ruth that Emil has attempted suicide before, prior to his last attempt; Ruth admits Emil has never told Ruth this, and Ariel says there may be a reason for that, then storms out of the house. Ruth calms herself by playing the piano. 

Chapter 17 Summary

Frank describes the Fourth of July festivities in New Bremen:

The procession marched along Main Street between cheering throngs and turned at Luther Avenue and continued a quarter mile to Luther Park which was full of vendors selling cotton candy and hot dogs and bratwurst and mini-donuts and helium-filled balloons. Every organization in town seemed to have a table where they hawked homemade pickles or baked goods or beautifully crocheted antimacassars and pot holders. There were games with prizes and there were polka bands and a temporary dance floor that had been laid out on the grass. There were shows in the band shell that included local musicians and storytellers and performers of odd feats. And there was a beer tent courtesy of the Brandt brewery (146).

 

Frank, Jake and Danny O’Keefe move through the festival’s happenings. Frank spots Morris Engdahl while waiting in line for the bathroom; when he’s done, and steps out of the restroom, Engdahl has vanished. Frank meets back up with Jake and Danny, who have since been joined by Warren Redstone. The group watch a baton twirler then a person reading the Declaration of Independence. Engdahl, drunk, locates Frank and grabs his arm. Redstone intervenes, asking Engdahl, “‘Are you the kind of man who fights only boys? Or would you be interested in fighting a man?’” (148). Engdahl again says that he’s going to kill Frank then leaves. Redstone queries Frank as to who Engdahl is, and Frank tells him about the incident at the quarry. Redstone responds by asking Frank, “‘You sure you don’t have any Sioux in you?’” (148).

The New Bremen Town singers take the stage to perform a chorale titled “The Freedom Road,” written by Ariel. Emil plays the piano and Ruth Drum conducts. Frank describes his sister: “That evening Ariel had worn a beautiful red dress. She wore a gold heart-shaped locket inset with mother-of-pearl and a mother-of-pearl barrette, both of which were heirlooms” (150). Warren Redstone offers that Ariel is “‘[p]retty enough to be Sioux’” (150).  

Frank and Jake return home; late in the night, Frank wakes to his father talking on the telephone—Ariel has yet to return home.  

Chapter 18 Summary

The next morning, Frank finds Sheriff Gregor, Karl Brandt, and a sheriff’s deputy in his home’s kitchen. Karl says that he and Ariel had been at a party on the bank of the river; alcohol had been involved, Karl had lost Ariel among the revelry, and no one has been able to locate her since.

Ruth phones Emil Brandt, hoping that Ariel is there, but Emil says she isn’t, and that he doesn’t know her whereabouts. The sheriffs head for Sibley Park, and Nathan says that he’ll join them there. Frank asks to come with him, and is surprised when Nathan says yes. Jake asserts that he’s coming as well. The Drums reach Sibley Park, where the remnants of the party the night prior remain: spent bonfires and beer cans, the husks of fireworks. Karl Brandt is there, along with the sheriffs. Brandt says that Morris Engdahl, very drunk, got into a fight with another boy over cars. Jake urges Frank to tell the sheriffs about Engdahl’s dislike of Ariel, which Frank does, passing along that Engdahl has called Ariel a “skag” and a “harelip” (157). Officer Doyle, also present, deems Engdahl “scum” (157). The group heads up the trail, toward the road, save for Doyle, who heads downriver. 

Chapters 15-18 Analysis

This group of chapters are the last prior to discovering that Ariel Drum is dead, and has been murdered. Her boyfriend, Karl Brandt, will be the book’s fourth and final death. As we move toward Ariel’s murder—the novel’s most pivotal plot point—Krueger establishes as many possibilities as he canfor who the culprit may be. Redstone remains a contender, and his comment that Ariel is pretty enough to be Sioux, while contextually ambiguous, is lent morbid potential. Morris Engdahl is brought to the forefront as a suspectas well, with his repeated threats of death toward Frank giving him motive for harming Ariel. Karl Brandt, while not yet explicitly a suspect, is presented here as at least theoretically hiding in plain sight, his concern for Ariel a means of throwing the authorities and the Drums off track. Finally, the depth of Ariel’s relationship with Emil is touched upon via the conversation between Ariel and Ruth, with Ariel revealing that she now knows more about Ruth’s former lover than Ruth does.

Frank’s relationship with Redstone is also deepened in these chapters; here, Redstone sticks up for and perhaps ultimately stops Engdahl from hurting Frank. This act of defense will affect proceeding action, in which Frank will make the choice to let Redstone flee New Bremen and evade questioning by authorities who are anxious to find Ariel’s killer.

The integrity of the relationship between Ruth Drum and Emil Brandt is called into question via the scene set in the college auditorium. Ultimately, this proves to be Krueger employing a red herring, throwing the reader off the scent of the actual, physical relationship that is in play, between Ariel Drum and Emil. It will be this relationship that ultimately leads to Lise Brandt killing Ariel; here, Krueger begins to move Emil, who has been presented up to this point as cynical and tragic, toward something dastardlier. 

blurred text
blurred text
blurred text
blurred text