50 pages • 1 hour read
Émile Zola, Transl. Gerhard KrügerA modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.
In the week after the race, Muffat arrives at Nana’s house and Zoe tells him that Nana is in bed recovering from a miscarriage. She has kept the pregnancy secret for months, annoyed and ashamed at her lack of control over her own body. Nana and Muffat do not discuss the miscarriage for long, though, because something else is bothering him. Nana quickly deduces that Rose must have sent him the letter proving Sabine’s affair. He wants to challenge Fauchery to a revenge duel and to separate from his wife. Nana counsels Muffat to stay married, however, and accept that he and Sabine will each have their separate liaisons.
Complicating matters further, Muffat is in financial trouble because of his lavish spending on Nana and a recent redecorating binge of Sabine’s. He can only repay the money he owes by selling a piece of property Sabine inherited, a transaction that would require her signature. With this matter unresolved, Muffat and Sabine throw a wedding party for their daughter Estelle and her new husband Daguenet. The same aristocratic ladies who attended Sabine’s salon are present and gossip about how far Muffat and Sabine have fallen. Chouard now hypocritically refuses to see his son-in-law because of his affair with Nana, and attends the party only for Estelle’s sake.
The afternoon of Daguenet and Estelle’s wedding, Daguenet shows up at Nana’s house. She has forgotten, but he once promised to give her his “innocence” on his wedding day. Amused, she invites him in to fulfill the promise.
One September evening, Muffat walks into Nana’s townhouse and finds her having sex with Georges. He is enraged, but she manages to calm him and avoid a split. Though Nana is as popular and admired as ever, her household is in complete chaos. She spends thoughtlessly, produces massive amounts of food waste, and does not notice that all of her servants are stealing from her regularly. She is planning her most absurd luxury yet: an ornate gilded bed, a throne for her lovers to worship her nakedness.
Philippe proposes to her, but she dismisses this as a ridiculous idea, as he could not fund her lifestyle. Shortly after, Madame Hugon receives word that Philippe has been arrested for stealing from his military regiment. Georges is gone too. Madame Hugon decides to pay Nana a visit.
Finding herself overwhelmed with bill collectors, Nana decides to accept some clients from the procuress Madame Tricon, a last resort she often takes advantage of in times of financial distress. On her way out the door, she runs into Georges, who begs her to marry him instead of Philippe. Annoyed, she tells him he has no right to expect anything from her. When she returns from her client, Georges is still in her bedroom. When she again refuses his offer of marriage, Georges stabs himself twice with a pair of scissors—just as his mother walks through the door, followed shortly by Muffat. Later, Zoe tries to clean the bloodstain off the floor, but cannot get it out. Nana hears that Georges is recovering slowly at Les Fondettes.
Meanwhile, Muffat’s personal life and Nana’s household have descended into even greater chaos. Sabine is sleeping with a rotating cast of men while Muffat feels guiltier than ever about his affair. Nana begins openly shoving her other affairs in his face, calling him disgusting. Her servants’ turnover is at an all-time high, and even Zoe plans to leave. Nana’s procession of lovers grows; she now picks up random men from the street. She has also taken up with other female lovers; in response, Satin throws loud, wild scenes. Nana takes Steiner back and ruins his newly-regained wealth in spectacular fashion, immediately afterward doing the same to La Faloise and Fauchery.
Nana starts to sexually degrade Muffat. She makes him talk like a baby and move like an animal. She even makes him wear his chamberlain uniform, then take it off, spit on it, and trample it underfoot.
One day, Muffat gets back earlier than expected from a trip to Normandy, where he had to sell his last remaining parcel of land to meet Nana’s financial demands. When he opens the bedroom door, he finds Nana on her new bed-throne with his father-in-law, the Marquis de Chouard. This is Muffat’s breaking point. He falls on his knees and starts praying for forgiveness. Miraculously, Monsieur Venot shows up at this precise moment and takes Muffat into his arms. Sabine has run off with a buyer from a draper’s shop, but the news barely fazes the shellshocked Muffat, who begs Venot, “Take me away … I have reached the end of my strength” (356).
Though he is financially ruined, Muffat picks up what pieces he can of his former life. Sabine eventually returns and he welcomes her back, excusing her actions as the effects of Nana’s influence. Estelle sues him for squandering her inheritance, and he is ejected from his position at court because of his and Sabine’s scandalous behavior. Despite this mounting tragedy, he is at peace, having finally broken free of Nana’s spell.
In the days following the breakup with Muffat, Nana learns that Zoe is leaving her, and Satin is in a hospital on the brink of death. Labordette appears and tells her that Georges has died, either of his stab wounds or some new suicide attempt. The news sends Nana into a spiral; she protests that she is not to blame for all these tragedies, exclaiming that all the ruined men in her orbit chose their downfall. After this diatribe, she feels better and immediately begins fantasizing about an even bigger, grander life. She sets out to visit Satin, “dressed in all her finery, clean, strong, and looking quite new, as though she had never been used” (362).
Near its conclusion, the novel moves at breakneck speed. For instance, while Chapter 1 took 26 pages to describe a single evening, during only five pages in Chapter 13, Nana financially ruins Steiner, Fauchery, and La Faloise, drives Philippe to commit crimes and go to prison, and inspires Georges to die by suicide in despair over her. With this rapid pacing, Zola evokes the sensation of a train careening down the tracks so quickly that it can only possibly crash.
Ultimately, however, Nana herself emerges from the crash unscathed, while Muffat and many of Nana’s other lovers suffer the damage. She has transformed Muffat from a pious, respected man into a degraded bestial creature who can only follow his appetites. Not only does she literally make him imitate an animal, but she also makes him destroy the symbol of his courtly position, his chamberlain’s uniform. She wants to bring him low and to destroy the objects that signal his social and financial superiority to her family of origin.
By showing the pile of ruined men in Nana’s wake, culminating in Comte Muffat, the man who resisted the longest but fell the hardest, Zola portrays Nana as a destroyer not just of men, but of Parisian society at large. Her unbridled sexuality is at fault for exposing the just barely repressed depravity, desire, and masochism of the upper classes. In the world of Nana, men with political, social, and economic power are powerless in the face of unchecked female sexuality, which reduces them to their instinctual responses. Similarly limited by innate deficiencies, Nana can never truly transform herself into a respectable woman because she is bound by birthright to her lower status. Zola describes a world where people are not in control of themselves, their appetites, or their life trajectories.
Though Nana cannot overcome her lower-class origins, she can avenge them. It is unclear to what extent Nana conceives of herself as an agent of class warfare who deliberately wants to humiliate France’s aristocracy, but the narrator clearly thinks of her as someone who accomplishes this end. As she recovers from her panic at the news of Georges’s death, the narrator tartly writes off her worries: “It was good, it was just, she had avenged her own people, the beggars and the outcasts” (362). Nana cannot elevate herself to the upper echelon, but she can drag others down.
By these authors
Beauty
View Collection
Books that Feature the Theme of...
View Collection
Books that Feature the Theme of...
View Collection
Challenging Authority
View Collection
Class
View Collection
Class
View Collection
European History
View Collection
French Literature
View Collection
Historical Fiction
View Collection
Nation & Nationalism
View Collection
Naturalism
View Collection
Power
View Collection
Realism
View Collection
School Book List Titles
View Collection
SuperSummary Staff Picks
View Collection
The Power & Perils of Fame
View Collection