63 pages • 2 hours read
Tara M. StringfellowA modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.
Content Warning: This section of the guide describes and discusses the source text’s treatment of domestic abuse, racism, racist violence, and child sexual abuse.
The narrative traces the lives of three generations of women in the North family who all exemplify resilience and claim an identity for themselves. They find power in creating their own lives while supporting each other. Hazel believed that racism undermined Black womanhood. The word girl “always sent Hazel into a silent rage” (104). Seeing white people calling her mother a girl, Hazel felt that “a grown and determined and brilliant woman, reduced to that colored girl in North Memphis” (104). Hazel always claimed her womanhood. She wanted people to address her as a “woman,” not as “girl.” Hazel was a strong woman who raised her daughters alone. She was pregnant when Myron was murdered. She went straight to work after his death, becoming the “first Black nurse” in the Mount Zion Baptist Hospital (62). Her experience of racism made Hazel determined to fight for equality. During the civil rights movement driven by her will to claim Black power and humanity, Hazel became a grassroots activist, making her house a hub for revolutionaries. Even though she had no other relatives left, she always found familial support in the Black community of the Douglass neighborhood.
When Miriam decides to leave her abusive husband, she and her daughters find shelter by her sister’s side in their family home. August and Miriam create a family anew and find power within their sisterhood. Miriam is still scared when she arrives in Memphis and recalls Jax’s bitter words that she cannot make it alone as a Black woman with two children. August encourages her sister and appeases her fears saying that she would make their mother proud. Miriam defies stereotypes and returns to school as a 40-year-old woman and mother, assuming her youth dream of becoming a nurse. Miriam craves independence, feeling “plain hungry” to make it on her own and “provide for her girls” without Jax’s support (56). August herself has managed to create a life for herself as a single mother. She did not pursue her musical gift and abandoned her college plans for motherhood, she created her own business with determination and perseverance, becoming a successful hairstylist. Despite dealing with her son’s delinquent behavior alone, August enjoys her independence deriving joy from the community of Black women: “August loved it all. The chaos. […] Even the poverty, the uncertainty” (87). Her salon becomes a communal female space for Black women which sustains August: “Laughter that could break glass. Laughter that could uplift a family. A cacophony of Black female joy in a language private to them” (87). The reunion of the North women proves to be empowering while the support of the Black community of the neighborhood remains pivotal and reassuring.
A gifted artist herself, August supports Joan’s choice to develop her artistic ability. When she realizes that Joan “has the gift” she immediately supports her niece while she recalls with some remorse how her path diverged from her singing talent: “Wanting Joan to always cherish her gift made her want to honor her own” (90). August believes in Joan and tries to reassure Miriam who is scared about her daughter’s future and financial safety. While Miriam’s fears make her momentarily doubt Joan’s ability to succeed as a Black woman artist, August reaffirms the resilience of Black women: “You asked that girl once to name you a famous artist who was a woman, who was Black. Joan Della North. That’s who. If she has to be the first, then so be it” (231). Ultimately, Miriam and August reunite and form a family of their own with courage and resilience. Carrying on Hazel’s legacy, a woman who fought for equality and faced life’s struggles with determination, they also pass it on to Joan who embarks on a new journey as a young woman. Her desire to paint the Black women of the Douglass neighborhood and make them her art project indicates that her art is also a means to discover her “self” as a Black woman.
Throughout the story, art and the characters’ love of art is cathartic and healing. Either directly or immediately, all the characters express their love of art. Joan’s grandfather Myron artfully painted the walls of their family home with flowers and important dates. As young people, Miriam and Jax bonded over discussing literature and music. August is very much in demand as a hair stylist, but she is also a gifted singer who always had a passion for music. Joan, as the focal character, powerfully expresses her passion for painting and its ability to offer her relief and joy. Art has healing power, as Joan finds an outlet to express her emotions and cope with her inner distress. Joan’s memories of her rape by Derek torment her and his presence in the same house is disturbing. Painting offers her comfort. Joan keeps her sketchbook with her always and wants to paint everything she loves, to “imprint it in […] [her] memory” (4). The Black women around her, like her Aunt August and Miss Dawn mesmerize her. Her desire to paint the “dark beauty” indicates her will to express the truth of Black womanhood in a society that oppresses it: “I wanted the world to see and to be ashamed” (74). August also reconnects to the power of her artistic charisma when she witnesses Joan’s ability in painting and supports her niece: “Wanting Joan to always cherish her gift made her want to honor her own” (90). August and Joan immediately realize the power of art. August decides to help her niece, thinking of her love of music and knowing that Joan has artistic gifts.
For Joan, art becomes a means to assuage her traumatic experience of rape. She finds a “refuge” in drawing and escapes her dark thoughts by throwing herself into her sketchbook: “If I concentrated on the sketch at hand, Derek would fade into the background of my life” (93). Miriam’s practical concerns about their survival causes her to doubt what art can do to “save” them. Despite feeling abandoned by her father, powerless in a discriminatory society, troubled by memories of her rape, and enraged towards Derek, Joan finds power in art. Painting nurtures and sustains her; it provides her with meaning and a sense of self. As such, it allows her to heal her inner traumas and discover herself against the odds. Joan realizes her vocation that directs her future: “I was born to be an artist. Placing pencil to page felt like worship each and every time. […] Art is air” (163). Miriam yields when she beholds the beauty of her daughter’s art. Ultimately, her art frees Joan. After her college admission, she realizes that freedom is also a “gift” that someone bears with love and perseverance.
The male aggression in the story negatively impacts the female characters. Several male characters in the story exemplify toxic masculinity. Joan is grappling with the traumatic experience of rape by Derek. She also witnesses her father’s abusive behavior when she sees him hitting her mother. Joan feels secure being around women and maleness is hostile and threatening to her. When she sees Derek for the first time after her rape in their family home, she considers him a “predator” who disturbs Joan’s peace in her “new safe haven” (7). As a woman, Joan feels that Derek comes from “an entirely different tribe” (7).
August also expresses her disappointment in men, feeling that most of them are angry and aggressive towards women and children. August’s own experience with Derek’s father and Derek’s demise makes her resent male violence. Derek expresses aggression and sexually assaults Joan when he was a teenager. His violent behavior continued as he broke a girl’s arm at school. Growing up, Derek becomes involved with the criminal gangs of Memphis. Police arrest him in connection with a murder. The court tries and convicts him and sentences him to life in prison. August reveals that Derek’s father was also an abusive man who mistreated his son: “Kind of man make you believe in evil in this world” (173). Derek’s father wanted his son to be a hard man and imposed on him a brutal discipline. August would often find Derek trembling and hiding. Derek’s father was stabbed to death in an altercation with another man. Male aggression exasperates August; she thinks it is destructive and hopeless: “Men and death. Men and death. How on earth y’all run the world when all y’all have ever done is kill each other?” (177).
Miriam survives domestic abuse. Even though Jax initially treated her well, his experience of warfare traumatized him and activated his aggressiveness. Jax is never violent towards his children, but his military training made him ground his masculinity in violence and force. Jax is a “broken man who beat Miriam in order to feel whole” (83). He accepts that the Gulf War “got the better of [him]” and is unable to redeem himself in Miriam’s eyes. She realizes that he is a man “ravaged by ghosts” (223). Joan begins to understand her father’s trauma and she becomes closer to him, but she cannot forgive him for his violence and inability to control himself.
The character of Myron contrasts the models of toxic masculinity in the text. Myron was “a man deep in love” characterized by “patience and diligence” (3). Myron’s love for his wife Hazel became “legendary” in the North family as Myron was always a nurturing, loving, and protective man who built their family home on his own. Myron also served in the Marine Corps during World War II. However, his experience of cruelty and atrocity never made him aggressive or abusive. Instead, Myron’s love for Hazel nurtured and shielded him from the cruelty of war: “The atrocities at each, the details of the carnage, Myron never included. Only his love for his new wife, his desire for the touch of her” (122). Toxic masculinity is a threat to the women in the story who manage to counter it by protecting and empowering each other.