logo

43 pages 1 hour read

Jennifer Egan

Manhattan Beach

Fiction | Novel | Adult | Published in 2017

A modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.

Themes

Gender and Socialization

Since childhood, Anna has traveled between the masculine world of her father and the feminine, domestic world of her mother and sister. She accompanies Eddie on his expeditions, becoming an accomplice of sorts, instrumental to his gaining preferment with superiors like Dexter. Although she has the masculine privilege of being out in the world, Anna draws on traditionally feminine soft skills— discretion and social agreeableness—to help her father with his business ventures. Her diplomatic skills continue at the home, where she lies to her mother to cover where she and her father have been.

In the world of her mother and sister, Anna is a practical helper and nurturer. The world the three of them inhabit—dancing until “all of them grew flushed” and “the small apartment shook and rang with a cheer,” which helps them try on coquetry and relive Agnes’s forsaken career as a Follies dancer—is “like a language that turn[s] to gibberish when [Eddie] listen[s]” (28). This gibberish parallels with Lydia’s echolalia, which Agnes and Anna attempt to respond to and Eddie does not. In their domestic realm, away from the outside eyes that would judge Lydia as freakish, they express themselves without being self-conscious. Nevertheless, Anna learns to sew, dance, and serve as a caretaker for Lydia.

When her father judges her too big to accompany him in the missions of his world, and she finds herself unable to be consigned to her mother’s domestic, feminine realm, Anna searches out her own secret world. She encounters a neighbor boy, Leon, and has sex with him, indulging a transgressive sexual curiosity forbidden to women at the time. When she seeks to become Lieutenant Axel’s first female diver, she penetrates depths that he and his sexist brigade deem inaccessible to her: “There were no facts. There was just him” (170), a man who opposes her wishes.

Like many forward-thinking women in wartime society, Anna traverses between the masculine world of adventure and ambition and the feminine world of domesticity. She takes a risky dive in New York Harbor at night, where she finds her father’s sunken pocket watch. When she keeps the watch, she inherits his legacy of adventuring and declaring her own destiny. At the same time, she also uses her feminine wiles, such as when she dons her mother’s sea-green strapless gown and seducing Dexter.

Later, when she becomes pregnant, Anna finds a way to balance her diving career with the task of gestating and caring for a baby. Rather than going back to the home and hiding her unwed motherhood in a sham marriage, as was typical of women in the postwar era, she charts her own course by moving to California, pretending to be the wife of a fallen soldier, and becoming a single, working mother. By the end of the novel, her father inhabits both gender roles as well; as he makes peace with his daughter Lydia and caresses his grandson, Eddie lives in domesticity with Anna and Brianne while he simultaneously provides for them. 

The Underdog

The cast of Manhattan Beach is comprised of underdogs; the progeny of Catholic immigrants, whether Polish, Italian, or Irish, are its starring characters. Following the Irish famine of the mid-19th century, Irish immigrants came to America in groves. They faced the same prejudice as Slavs and Southern Europeans, who were subject to a quota by the 1924 Immigration Act. One aspect of shared identity between these immigrants was the Catholic religion; another was the shared experience of being second-class citizens. Even as late as the wartime years, wops, micks and Polacks shared a sense of understanding, both within each distinctive group and as an immigrant collective.

America provides an extraordinary opportunity for immigrants to improve their fortunes, but the Darwinian nature of capitalism pits the underdogs against one another. Anna, age 12, visits Dexter’s house and notices that “from the broad lay of her face and the merry switch of her eyes that Nurse was Irish, and felt a danger of being seen through” (5). Anna worries that her family’s impoverished situation, similar to that of newer Irish immigrants, will become apparent if Nurse realizes they are of similar descent.

As micks and Protectory men, Dunellen and Eddie rely on each other in America’s ruthless capitalist system, but they also act against one another to promote their own interests. Instead of lending him money, Dunellen sends Eddie to a loan shark; Eddie forsakes Dunellen for Dexter, when the former will not pay him enough. When Eddie becomes a hazard to him, Dexter attempts to kill Eddie; the wop Mr. Q. (in cahoots with Dexter’s WASP father-in-law) has Dexter shot in the back when he becomes a liability.

Anna and Marle’s camaraderie defies the “everyone for themselves” paradigm of Eddie’s generation, showing that collaboration usurps competition when it comes to raising people up. As members of two disadvantaged groups, they act to promote the other’s good. In turn, they advance themselves. 

Life on the Homefront

Manhattan Beach takes place during the Second World War, and though the heart of the fighting is in Europe, many of the characters are involved in the war effort in America. Egan shows how the war plays a role in larger social changes, but on the Homefront, the true battles are personal, rooted in local places and events. Nineteen-year-old Anna leaves Brooklyn College to work in Mr. Voss’s factory, where she measures ship parts alongside married women obsessed with their soldier husbands. Although she has a job because of the war, the war seems “maddeningly abstract, at too great a distance to be felt” (66). Seeking to become part of the action, Anna trawls Naval Yard during her lunch hour, finding out how each factory contributes to the war effort. She plans to buy war bonds and learns to become a diver, so she can also be part of something challenging and dangerous.

Anna’s most important battles, however, have nothing to do with Allies vs. Axis. She battles to learn the truth about her father, who disappeared before the war began; her most dangerous dive is for him. Even so, Anna considers her life a “war life; the war was her life. There had been another life before that” (472). When she becomes pregnant out of wedlock, her aunt imagines that the perpetrator is an irresistible soldier in uniform, not the gangster who presided over her father’s disappearance. Anna also battles to live life on her own terms, challenging the gender norms of the day. She begins anew with her aunt and baby son on the other side of the country; even as an unwed mother and professional diver, she refuses to be judged by the standards of a time that she considers obsolete.

War also frames the storylines of other home front characters. Tabatha is devastated when her cousin Grady leaves for war, and Dexter romanticizes the sight of the young man in uniform, feeling “his throat tighten as he [shakes] his nephew’s hand” owing to his “eerie intimation that he wouldn’t see him again” (327). Dexter’s premonition proves correct; his demise, however, is in nothing as heroic as war. He pays for a result of subordination to Mr. Q., even knowing that the latter can turn on him whenever he chooses.

Although Eddie is seen as a “war hero” following his expedition at sea, he only achieves true heroism when he atones for abandoning his family and failing his youngest daughter. When he makes amends during his starvation at sea by “following Lydia” and communicating with her in “a language he’d once discounted but now, at last, could understand” (455), he discovers a new capacity to love and change, eventually earning Anna’s forgiveness and renewed trust. 

blurred text
blurred text
blurred text
blurred text