logo

44 pages 1 hour read

Michel Tremblay

Les Belles Soeurs

Fiction | Play | Adult | Published in 1968

A modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.

Themes

The Role of Women in Society

All 15 characters in Les Belles-Soeurs are women, and the play focuses on the behavior of these women—particularly those of Germaine’s generation—in the private, domestic arena. These women are in their forties and fifties and mostly housewives. They see the path to respectability and a proper life as clear and based on the tenets of Catholicism: get married and obey their husbands, or don’t marry and stay celibate. For those with husbands, “obeying” means accepting the endless cycle of housework and drudgery, taking care of the kids, providing sex (without birth control) when the husband wants it, and performing any variation on these duties that arises at any time of the day or week. For instance, Thérèse must care for her mother-in-law, Olivine, because caretaking falls within the realm of women’s domestic responsibilities. The unmarried characters show that the life of a spinster is not pleasant either. Des-Neiges is lonely and desperate for the attention of a man. Angéline has found the first pleasure of her life by making friends at the nightclub and drinking occasionally. Rhéauna has preoccupied herself with piety and chastity but stoops to stealing for the sake of a dustpan.

The play’s last vestige of the older generation is Olivine, Thérèse’s mother-in-law. Due to her infirmities and disabilities, she has no agency left. She also has no voice. In contrast to the women who argue, speak heartfelt monologues about their inner lives, and advocate for themselves, Olivine is largely silent. The women have little regard or respect for her as an elder. Thérèse beats and abuses her into submission, and Rose wishes that Thérèse would kill her. Olivine reminds the women of what they will soon become, living at the mercy of the children they’re currently raising. The women’s relationships with their children are based on discipline rather than love, so they fear the day that their daughters or daughters-in-law will be in charge of their well-being. They try to push their children to make better decisions than they did, but their brashness makes their advice seem more judgmental than helpful. Germaine tries to tell Linda that marrying Robert will lead to a miserable life, but Linda ignores her because Germaine sounds more critical than concerned. Rose describes trying to keep her daughter from her own fate of a miserable marriage by telling her that men are worthless.

There are changes in the ethos of the new generation. The play’s three young women—Linda, Ginette, and Lise—defend going to restaurants and nightclubs, which their mothers find scandalous. Linda may end up with Robert, but she demonstrates on the phone that she will fight back when he doesn’t treat her kindly. Lise is ready to terminate her pregnancy in pursuit of a better life than the one her mother leads. There are certainly vestiges of conservatism, such as Ginette’s prejudice against unwed mothers and Linda’s criticism of Lise’s decision to abort. However, the play is set around 1965, and the birth control pill became available in 1960. As Pierrette points out, it’s now an option for women who want to avoid pregnancy without abstinence. Furthermore, although abortion is illegal, it is becoming more safely accessible through an underground network of doctors. The younger women may choose the Catholic principles that preclude these options, but the fact that women can increasingly control their own reproduction signals the coming change in women’s societal roles.

The Sexual Coercion and Assault of Women

During the era in which the play is set, society—particularly religious traditionalists—expected women to submit to their husbands and did not consider coercive sex within marriage to be rape. The play’s female characters understand random attacks from strangers—e.g., the unhoused man who touches Marie-Ange in the movie theater—as sexual assault, and they arm themselves to fight back against them. However, they don’t recognize women’s vulnerability to coerced consent and instead blame women for giving in to male pressure. For instance, Pierrette’s sisters see Johnny as a terrible influence who led Pierrette astray from a pious life, but they also ostracize and hate Pierrette for it. They don’t see that Pierrette was young and in love or that Johnny manipulated her in order to use her, which becomes clear when Pierrette explains that he dumped her suddenly because she has aged. Similarly, the man who impregnated Lise made empty promises to her in order to coerce her consent. Then he vanished from her life, leaving her alone and pregnant.

Rose in particular seems to have a traumatic relationship with sex, which she attempts to bury under humor and judgment. After the first line of Des-Neiges's joke indicates that it is about a nun who was raped, Rose even exclaims, “Sounds good!” (45). Rose is the most vocal about claiming to want sex; when the neighbor threatens to call the police, Rose jokes that the party needs more men anyway. She is also the most critical of younger people and their sexual desires. When she finds out that her son is potentially having sex with the daughter of the Italian family, Rose is disgusted and calls him a pig like his father. Upon learning the gossip about the young woman who has become pregnant, possibly by her stepfather, Rose is quick to blame her as well as any unwed pregnant woman. In her monologue, however, Rose shows a more vulnerable side, confessing that her husband demands sex twice a day and that she despises it. The Catholic principles that forbid birth control mean that unwanted sex with her husband also leads to unwanted procreation, further enmeshing her in the homemaking role the women find so stifling. In Canada, marital rape did not become illegal until 1983.

Capitalism and Consumerism

The characters in the play are working class, which means that they are at the bottom of the class hierarchy. As women and housewives, they also have very little agency over the financial status and wealth of their households. The women are neighbors and therefore within the same socioeconomic sphere. Nevertheless, they still participate in the capitalist game of competitive consumerism. They don’t commiserate with one another regarding their poverty but hide their struggles in shame, only truly opening up in the monologues and moments of non-realistic poetry. They value themselves and each other based on visible displays of financial wealth, the social currency of respectability, and the general idea of winning and good luck; capitalist culture thus exacerbates the women’s hypocrisies and petty cruelties. Thérèse turns the burden of caretaking into a performance to show off her selflessness while also implying Olivine’s presence is a consequence of her family’s increased wealth. Lisette affects high-class sophistication, looking down on the others, who she genuinely believes are lower than her. She wishes that she could never see or think about these women again, but the fact that she is there shows that she likely doesn’t have more upper-class options.

Germaine, with her sweepstakes win, is the woman of the hour. She is queen for a day, and the others show up regardless of their resentment and envy. Germaine uses her power to create a literal sweatshop, expecting her friends to work in a cramped kitchen and refusing to open the window because the stamps might blow away. She offers no sharing or compensation but a pittance of meager refreshments—too few bottles of Coke (which she forgets to serve at first), some peanuts, and potato chips. However, Germaine’s expectations for the array of things that she will buy with her stamps become unrealistic over the course of the play. She fantasizes about buying not only what she needs and can use, but also things like a lawn mower, even though she doesn’t have a lawn. Saying that she will spend money on something that she doesn’t want or need is a way of claiming that she has reached the level of having expendable income.

Like Germaine, the women see a million stamps as an infinite amount. They steal surreptitiously as if they won’t get caught, not realizing how quickly they will hit the limits of a million and make their theft obvious. In reality, the stamps are worthless bits of paper that allow housewives to feel as if they are accumulating actual currency. Grocery and department stores issue them as customer rewards to create more customer loyalty by making spending feel like earning. Stamps have to be pasted into booklets to be redeemed—a tedious task that requires time and organization, both of which a put-upon housewife would struggle to find and maintain. Furthermore, while a million is certainly a lot of stamps, the fact that Rhéauna needs three booklets (in addition to whatever stamps she has collected herself) to buy a single dustpan suggests that they don’t stretch terribly far.

The women’s constant participation in contests that they don’t win is similarly futile. They perform an “Ode to Bingo” because they value door prizes, even though those prizes are typically junk such as doorstops and ashtray floor lamps. At the end, the women revert to an individualistic capitalist free-for-all, performing the animalistic struggle that they have been battling all along in more polite, metaphorical ways.

blurred text
blurred text
blurred text
blurred text