logo

48 pages 1 hour read

Beatriz Williams

Husbands & Lovers

Fiction | Novel | Adult | Published in 2024

A modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.

Chapters 12-18Chapter Summaries & Analyses

Chapter 12 Summary: “Mallory. August 2008. Winthrop Island, New York”

Mallory awakens to find Monk asleep beside her, and they hear Chippy and Blue thundering toward her bedroom. Monk hides under the bed until they go. He is ready to tell the world that he and Mallory are a couple, but she thinks that it’d be tacky since she’s the nanny. They go to the beach and make love. Neither has a condom, but Mallory is certain that she won’t get pregnant because her period just ended. Monk kisses her on the walk back, and the kids and Becca see it. Blue reports that Becca called Mallory a “bitch.” That night, on their way to Mo’s, Monk introduces Mallory to his aunt Barbara, his mother’s sister and the woman who raised him. Barbara asks if Mallory is Monk’s “muse,” and he confirms it. Before taking the stage, Monk tells Mallory that he loves her. Barbara says that Monk’s mom has been in rehab several times and describes his dad as a serial philanderer. Mallory recognizes her ex, Dillon, across the room. She broke up with him two days after she and Monk kissed, and when he asked if there was someone else, she told him about Monk. He and Mallory chat for a moment before Monk appears. Dillon punches Monk in the face.

Chapter 13 Summary: “Mallory. June 2022. Cape Cod, Massachusetts”

Mallory gets an email from the convent of St. Hilda’s in Galway, Ireland, explaining that they cannot share confidential records without identification and a copy of her mother’s adoption certificate. A week ago, Monk asked if he could text Sam, and she gave permission, telling Monk about Sam’s condition and what caused it. Monk asked about Sam’s medical bills and whether he could give Sam his kidney. Mallory realizes that, if Monk had been part of Sam’s life, she probably wouldn’t have sent him to summer camp because he’d have gone to Winthrop Island instead. Monk promises to pay for the best possible care for Sam going forward.

Later, Paige says that Jake must work over the Fourth of July weekend. Mallory mentions her friend, Luca, who does appraisals for Sotheby’s. They meet for lunch, and she asks him about her cobra bracelet. He guesses that it’s from Egypt, around the 1930s. He takes pictures and promises to get back to her. When Mallory returns to Paige’s house, Monk and Sam are playing catch. Monk asks her permission to take Sam to Winthrop Island for the holiday weekend; it’d be just the two of them, though he will hire a nurse to administer Sam’s dialysis. Monk presents Mallory with a paternity agreement that details child support of $25,000 a month. He proposes to place $4 million—what he would have paid for the first 12 years of Sam’s life—in an escrow account for Sam. He also asks for visitation rights. After he leaves, Paige suggests that she and Mallory go to Ireland for a few days.

Chapter 14 Summary: “Hannah. December 1951. Outside Cairo, Egypt”

Hannah feels little guilt about her affair with Lucien, though she believes that Alistair suspects it. Alistair goes to Rome for some meetings, so Hannah and Lucien travel to Alexandria, checking into a hotel as Mr. and Mrs. Beck. Lucien wants to know what Hannah wants from their relationship, besides a baby. He loves her, and he eventually realizes that she does love him. The next morning, Hannah notes her tender breasts and slightly swollen belly. When she goes to the dining room for breakfast, a woman calls out, “Why, Countess Vécsey!” speaking to Hannah in Hungarian (286). She says that she believed that Hannah was dead, but Hannah tells the woman that she has mistaken Hannah for someone else.

Later, Lucien asks Hannah about the woman. She lies, but he overheard them speaking Hungarian, so she tells him that the woman was an old friend. He asks what Alistair is doing in Rome, and she offers to find out if it will help the Egyptians get their country back. That afternoon, Lucien introduces Hannah to his mother, Madame Suarez, and Hannah is shocked to learn that the woman’s family were Jews, forced to leave Spain during the Inquisition. When Hannah and Lucien return to Cairo two days later, he asks again if she’s willing to report on her husband’s work in Rome, and she is. Lucien warns her that it might be dangerous, but she reminds him of her pistol. He asks if she’s ever killed someone before, and she admits that she has.

Hannah recalls the winter of 1941, when she lived in Hungary with János and their son, Mìklos. János insisted that Hannah learn how to load and fire a gun because he would leave soon to fight the Germans. That night, their daughter, Lèna, was born. Now, when Hannah enters her apartment, Alistair is back. She asks him about Rome, and they have sex.

Chapter 15 Summary: “Mallory. August 2008. Winthrop Island, New York”

Mallory drives Monk and Barbara back after Mo’s. As Mallory heads upstairs, Mr. Adams calls to her from the terrace. He offers her a joint, and she takes it. Becca, he says, wants him to fire Mallory, but he won’t. Instead, he offers to be like a godfather to her, mentioning that he’s shown some of her work to colleagues at a Boston art museum. After they talk, Mallory finds Monk in the guest house, and they have sex again. The next morning, Monk asks when her last day of work is, revealing his concern that their relationship will end with summer. He says, “It hurts, Pink. Like a pain in my chest, like it’s too much to hold. Like I might lose you” (316). Mallory feels that being apart will be “bleak,” but she promises that they’ll see one another on breaks. He suggests that they go away together when she’s finished with work, before they must leave for school. They agree to leave Winthrop Island in one week, on August 15.

Chapter 16 Summary: “Mallory. July 2022. County Galway, Ireland”

Mallory and Paige drive to the convent where their mother was born. On the way, Paige reveals that she found a $7,000 charge from Cartier on Jake’s credit card, and she thinks that he’s having an affair. When they arrive, one nun gives them a tour, and she tells them that the women who gave birth here were given chloroform and told that their babies had died. American families paid a lot of money for healthy babies. Mallory and Paige meet the aged Mother Superior, Bernadette, who delivered their mother. The woman recognizes Mallory’s bracelet. She tells them that their grandmother was dropped off by a man, and he told them that she was in a fire; her hair was burned very short. The woman’s name was Hannah Ainsworth, and Bernadette only heard Hannah speak once, when her daughter was born; “She has his eyes” (339), she said. Bernadette always believed that it was the husband’s wish to give the child up, not Hannah’s. Hannah screamed when they took her baby, and she gave Bernadette the cobra bracelet, begging her to give it to the parents for her little girl. Then, the day before her husband was to come, a woman collected Hannah. That night, in the hotel, Mallory thinks about how her eyes are the same green as her mother’s. While Paige takes a shower, Monk texts, saying that Jake is on the news.

Chapter 17 Summary: “Hannah. January 1952. Cairo, Egypt”

Hannah dines with Alistair and the Beverleys, and she is definitely pregnant. Lillian whispers to her that the Egyptians “want to burn it all down […]. To make us leave” (348). Hannah goes outside to get some air, and Lucien finds her, telling her she must leave Egypt because it is no longer safe. She returns to Alistair, and he suggests that they return to England. When Hannah asks if the rising tensions have anything to do with the man he shot, Alistair speaks harshly to her, telling her to shut her “silly mouth” and “[k]eep to [her] bloody gossip and frocks” (353). That night, Hannah sees Lucien embracing Lillian.

Hannah remembers when János came home, nearly two months after the defeat at Stalingrad. She assumed that he was dead, and she didn’t recognize him at first because he was so emaciated. It took months for his health to recover, and when it did, he asked about their kids. Hannah told him that they had all got typhoid, and Mìkos and Lèna had not survived.

Chapter 18 Summary: “Mallory. July 2022. Winthrop Island, New York”

Paige is on the phone with her lawyers about Jake’s affair. She and Mallory are staying on Monk’s estate. Mallory thanks Monk for letting them stay with him, and he’s glad because he gets to spend more time with Sam. They are eating dinner together when Lennox Lassiter arrives. Mallory’s throat gets dry and Lennox—who goes by Lee—embraces Sam and tells him that she’s going to be his stepmom. Lee tries to ingratiate herself with Mallory, asking if they can be friends. She describes how she got Monk in therapy after his dad died, and that’s when she learned about Mallory. Lee and Monk met when they were 10 years old, then reconnected in college, and then again when his dad got sick. Later, Mallory finds Grace crying, and Grace asks if her cooking is “too old-fashioned,” but Grace won’t say who made this harsh comment to her.

Mallory mentions to Monk that she didn’t realize that Lee was a former girlfriend. He says that she was there for him when his dad got sick, and she helped him work through his feelings. He always blamed his dad for Mallory leaving, assuming that he had “talked [her] out of it or something” (379). He explains that Lee loved him before he got famous, so he felt that he could trust her; his dad loved her, too. Monk leaves to take a phone call, and Paige watches the kids at the pool while Mallory investigates the 1952 fire in Cairo known as “Black Saturday.” She overhears Lee speaking very imperiously and rudely to someone on the phone. When Lee realizes that Mallory overheard, she’s embarrassed and renews her wish that she and Mallory become “like sisters.”

That night, Paige tells Mallory that Lola is happy to host them again. Paige thinks that it’s too hard for Mallory to be here with Lee. Paige doesn’t like Lee because she is fake and exploitative. Mallory agrees that they should go back to Lola’s tomorrow. Before leaving, Paige shows her the DNA profile she had done, and Mallory learns that they are one-quarter Jewish.

Chapters 12-18 Analysis

Lucien’s behavior in this section suggests hidden truths and foreshadows future revelations. Most significantly, he asks Hannah for information about Alistair’s business in Rome, and upon their return to Cairo, he even confirms to make sure that she’s still willing to provide him with information. This behavior is atypical for his character thus far. Furthermore, Lillian once told Hannah that Lucien had an affair with another English diplomat’s wife, and Hannah herself sees Lucien intimately embracing Lillian. These facts call Lucien’s identity and motives into question. However, he tells Hannah repeatedly that he loves her, introduced her to his Jewish mother, and told Hannah that she must leave Egypt for her own safety. Moreover, he trusts her with the knowledge that he is a Jew living in an Arab country during a particularly contentious time, following the creation of Israel and the Arab-Israeli War of 1948. Thus, Lucien is certainly deceiving someone, though whether that someone is Hannah, the Egyptian government, or another party altogether, remains to be seen until Chapter 19 reveals that he is an Israeli intelligence agent. This mystery illuminates one of the text’s themes: The Deceptiveness of Appearances. Lucien may seem like an unassuming, lovesick hotel manager, but his actions and desire for information suggest something else.

Lee also highlights this theme. Though she presents herself as a loving and sensitive “empath [who] feels everyone’s pain” (372), asking Mallory to “open [her]self [up]” to Lee (371), her behavior when she isn’t being scrutinized paints a different picture of her real self. Everyone loves Grace, the woman who works for the Adams family, but Mallory finds her crying after someone told her that her “cooking is too ‘old-fashioned’” (377). The narrative implies that the person who said this was Lee. This is made more probable given what Mallory overhears when Lee is on the phone. Lee claims to be “stuck” with the person she addresses, even calling the listener “honey” in a condescending way, telling her to “pull on [her] big-girl pants and get this shit done exactly the way [Lee] told [her] to” (383). The entirety of Lee’s reprimand is printed in bold, emphasizing her sarcastic and patronizing tone and her overbearing nature. Lee presents herself as sweet, but her actions indicate a different, hidden truth.

Several other clues foreshadow future revelations. For one, Paige and Mallory’s biological grandmother commented on the green color of her baby’s eyes, a trait that Mallory inherited from her mother, and this links them to Lucien. Furthermore, the implication that Alistair drove Hannah to the convent confirms that he is the one who wanted to give the baby up, suggesting that he must know about Hannah’s affair, as he would be unlikely to give up a child of his own. The narrative portrayal of the affair creates dramatic irony and heightens tension before Alistair’s realization of the truth. Hannah’s pregnancy provides a time limit for this realization, since she is already showing, which increases the narrative tension. Further, Mallory’s investigation of “Black Saturday” and Bernadette’s description of Hannah, who was burned and scarred when she arrived at the convent, suggest that Lillian is right when she tells Hannah the Egyptians want to “burn it all down” and “make [the English] leave” (348). These details foreshadow Hannah’s future entrapment in the Cairo fire. Likewise, Alistair’s cruelty and dismissiveness suggest that he knows of Hannah’s affair or, at least, that he is capable of being pitiless. He implies that she is stupid and tells her to confine her comments to gossip and dresses, as though she hasn’t the intelligence to think of other things. He cruelly describes her as “bloody indecent” with her “[t]its spilling out. Arse spilling out” (353). Such language signals the breakdown of their relationship, which is also suggested by the fact that someone else picks Hannah up from the convent before he arrives.

As the narrator reveals more about Hannah’s past, her experiences illustrate the theme of Female Perseverance and Strength. She had a young son and a newborn daughter when Jànos left home to fight in World War II. Then, after the army’s defeat at Stalingrad, she “laid him to rest in the mud of the Volga riverbank” (346). Believing he was dead, Hannah forced herself to move forward for her children. Then, she became feverish with typhoid, the disease that claimed Mìklos and Lèna. Finally, Jànos returns, but he is so ill that she must nurse him for months before he could even look “like a skeleton” (355), a simile that highlights how ghastly he appeared when he first returned and contributes to the morbid imagery throughout the text. Thus, despite having been through terrible physical and emotional pain, Hannah finds strength to comfort her husband, return him back to life, and live again, herself. This perseverance and mental and physical strength are unmatched by any other character in the text.

blurred text
blurred text
blurred text
blurred text