logo

59 pages 1 hour read

Mark Harmon

Ghosts of Honolulu: A Japanese Spy, A Japanese American Spy Hunter, and the Untold Story of Pearl Harbor

Nonfiction | Book | Adult | Published in 2023

A modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.

Parts 5-6Chapter Summaries & Analyses

Part 5: “Two Waves”-Part 6: “Hunting Ghosts”

Part 5, Chapter 1 Summary: “Japanese Aircraft Carrier Akagi”

Captain Minor Genda is aboard the Akagi awaiting a final intel report from the consulate in Hawaii in the dawn hours of December 7, 1941. Admiral Chichi Nagumo announces that the attack will not focus on infrastructure, as Genda hoped, but rather on the battleships moored at the harbor.

Part 5, Chapter 2 Summary: “Kama Lane”

Douglas Wada and his friends head out to fish Diamond Head Bay, abandoning their normal fishing spot in Pearl Harbor after finding their bait cache gone.

Part 5, Chapter 3 Summary: “USS Helm (DD-388)”

On deck the USS Helm at 8:00 am, Lieutenant Commander Chester Carroll and his 13-year-old son hear the buzz of approaching aircraft. One bombs a nearby airfield, and Carroll orders a counterattack. The USS Helm, after a brief delay, returns fire on Japanese planes. His gunners take out a plane, but he quickly realizes the planes are not attacking his ship, but the harbor itself. Carroll escapes the harbor and takes aim at a small sub stuck in the reef.

Part 5, Chapter 4 Summary: “Tripod Reef”

Their gyrocompass broken, the two Japanese seamen in the sub know they are doomed. They are not destroyed, but are cut off from the harbor and on the hunt for another target.

Part 5, Chapter 5 Summary: “4401 Kahala Ave”

Shivers is at home when he gets the call informing him that Japan has attacked the harbor. He orders his wife to keep their Japanese exchange student Sue with her at all times, and leaves.

Part 5, Chapter 6 Summary: “Japanese Consulate”

Takeo Yoshikawa watches the smoke rise from the harbor and knows the attack has finally come. On the radio, the announcer delivers a coded message: “Eat wind, rain,” meaning Japan has initiated war with the US (116). Consul General Kita and Takeo Yoshikawa burn code books and vital secrets as police sirens approach the consulate, the sounds of mortars and aircraft nearby. Before they are all arrested, they are unable to burn documents in the safe relating to Otto Kuehn.

Part 5, Chapter 7 Summary: “Diamond Head Beach”

Douglas Wada rushes from the beach and is stopped by a police car; the officer informs him that someone is looking for Wada.

Part 5, Chapter 8 Summary: “Over the Navy Yard”

Lieutenant Commander Takashige Egusa’s dive-bomber unit is headed for the USS New Orleans. He misses, as do most. They are not devastating the fleet, as they had hoped. Admiral Nagumo has not attacked the infrastructure around the Harbor, only the planes and battleships, and the US Navy will be able to recover quickly. In total, 18 American ships have sunk. Two thousand four hundred and three Americans die in the attack, with another 1,143 wounded. Admiral Nagumo dispatches word that the attack was a success.

Part 5, Chapter 9 Summary: “Alexander Young Hotel”

At home Wada learns that people are searching for him, and he dons his uniform before rushing to the office, where Mayfield says they will soon have plenty to keep him busy.

Part 5, Chapter 10 Summary: “Federal Building”

Gero Iwai, Army intelligence, is present as SAC Shivers finalizes a 400+ list of Japanese in Hawaii to detain. Martial law has been declared, and General Short has the authority to begin arresting people. In DC, Roosevelt signs Proclamation 2525, allowing for the arrest of any and all Japanese living in the US. The detainees are held in an immigration building.

Part 5, Chapter 11 Summary: “Alexander Young Hotel”

Hawaii is on edge, and Wada is worried his heritage will make him a target as citizens and soldiers act more out of fear than reason. Ted Emanuel asks if Wada wants to survey the damage, and Wada agrees. At the wharf, soldiers open fire on them and they flee, returning to the offices at the Alexander Young Hotel.

Part 5, Chapter 12 Summary: “Below Field Beach”

Soldiers respond to reports of a strange item in the surf on the beach. They find a naked and freezing mini submarine commander who becomes the first American-held prisoner of WWII.

Part 5, Chapter 13 Summary: “Iolani Palace”

Lt. Col. Thomas Green moves into Iolani Palace after martial law is declared in Hawaii, and he listens to Roosevelt’s address. Japan attacked Hong Kong, Guam, the Philippine Islands, Midway Island, and the Wake Islands on December 7 and 8, and Roosevelt asks Congress to declare war with Japan. In the palace, Green thinks of how martial law will play out in Hawaii, including press censorship, the suspension of habeas corpus, and the seizure of medical and first-response facilities. Amid the arrestees are Otto Kuehn and his family of spies.

Part 5, Chapter 14 Summary: “Alexander Young Hotel”

The prisoner from the beach is brought to the hotel, where Wada and Iwai feel little pity for him. They are asked to interrogate the prisoner and are ordered to do it correctly because it is the first American interrogation of the war. They learn that the man’s gyrocompass broke, and he is bathed in shame. They further learn that the attack was meant to do much more than it achieved and that the mini sub was not scuttled properly. They find the sub and, with it, maps and updated charts that reveal how accurate and extensive the spy network in the Japanese consulate was.

Part 5, Chapter 15 Summary: “Federal Building”

Wada and Iwai are tasked with taping together the ripped and partially burnt papers from the Japanese consulate, which prove mostly fruitless.

Part 5, Chapter 16 Summary: “Kama Lane”

Although Wada’s father was not arrested, the Shinto reverend who married Wada was. Wada sits in a parked car outside his father’s shrine.

Part 6, Chapter 1 Summary: “Alexander Young Hotel”

The deciphers cables finally arrive on Mayfield’s desk and reveal Consul General Kita’s pre-attack messages to the Japanese fleet. They had the intel three days before the attack, but not the means to get it deciphered or translated quickly enough. There is also evidence of the Nazi spy ring, which they quickly realize is Kuehn’s family.

Part 6, Chapter 2 Summary: “Department of the Navy”

Frank Knox, Secretary of the Navy, visits Hawaii and reports that fifth-column work made the attack possible. The general attitude toward Japanese in the area sours. While more Issei are arrested, the Nisei respond with acts of America loyalty.

Lt. General Delos Emmons replaces General Short; Emmons now has complete control of Hawaii under martial law. He assesses the situation and concludes that the islands are not awash in seditious actors; he promises not to act against the Japanese American population.

Part 6, Chapter 3 Summary: “Japanese Consulate”

Takeo Yoshikawa believes his cover is holding until he, Seki, Okuda, and consul-general Kita are taken by ship toward the American mainland.

Part 6, Chapter 4 Summary: “Federal Building”

Investigators grill Kimie Doue, a Nisei working as a secretary in the Japanese consulate. She is a wealth of intel, especially on Takeo Yoshikawa and Kuehn. She also tells them about a driver who ferries Yoshikawa around Oahu.

Part 6, Chapter 5 Summary: “Federal Building”

Agents interrogate Kotoshirodo, Yoshikawa’s driver, and conclude that it is Yoshikawa who, under the name Tadashi Morimura, mapped the Naval defenses for the Japanese attack. With the spies and their network now documented and understood, Hoover asks Roosevelt what to do with the perpetrators.

Part 6, Chapter 6 Summary: “Alexander Young Hotel”

The US military will no longer allows Japanese Americans (Nisei) to participate in the military. Wada and Iwai believe they will be fired. Wada confronts Mayfield, who has him meet with Lt. Cecil Coggins, a talented obstetrician who has been recruiting his own network of Nisei informants for the Navy. Coggins helps draft a report on Nisei loyalty, which reaches Emmons’s and Nimitz’s desks.

Part 6, Chapter 7 Summary: “San Pedro YMCA”

In California, Ken Ringle can see the tides of popular opinion turning against the Japanese in America and hopes his work on Nisei loyalty will help change that. His report suggests there are less than 300 Japanese Americans who actually wish the US harm and that they represent no greater risk than German Americans. The Ringle report, in tandem with Shivers’s reports from Hawaii convince J. Edgar Hoover that the “Japanese Problem” has been overblown. In February, Roosevelt sides against Hoover, Shivers, and Ringle, issuing Executive Order 9066, allowing for detention without a hearing for any citizen. By March, Japanese Americans near military zones in California are rounded up.

Part 6, Chapter 8 Summary: “French Frigate Shoals”

Two Japanese sea planes refuel mid-ocean before continuing on to Oahu to bomb what’s left of Pearl Harbor on a morale-destroying mission. The seaplanes drop their payloads in the wrong place, and there is no impact except that Admiral Nimitz mines the shoals where the planes refueled. Station Hypo reveals that their intel on the shoals was correct, and they soon realize the next attack will come at Midway.

Part 6, Chapter 9 Summary: “Triangle T Guest Ranch”

Yoshikawa is being housed at Triangle T Guest House in remote Arizona. He reveals little in interrogations and enjoys kind treatment from the Americans, who play tennis and baseball with their captives. Consul general Kita asks Yoshikawa to take the blame for everything himself, but Yoshikawa will not.

Part 6, Chapter 10 Summary: “Department of Agriculture”

Milton Eisenhower, brother to Dwight Eisenhower, is tasked with heading the War Relocation Authority (WRA) in California. His mandate is to detain all Japanese and hold them until the conclusion of the war. Eisenhower asks Ringle for help, and he drafts a report on how to incarcerate the population with the intent of reintegrating them and possibly enlisting many. He then leaks his report to the press.

Part 6, Chapter 11 Summary: “The Presidio”

General John DeWitt orders the detention of every Japanese American and resident on the West Coast within 48 hours. One arrest revealed several members of the Black Dragon Society, an organized crime group largely seen as anti-American. The media devours this detail, sensationalizing it. Of the 120,000, some 70,000 are American citizens.

In Hawaii, the response is tempered and Emmons does not undertake mass arrests. Ringle, Shivers, and others are respected, and their reports have sway. Many are arrested and sent to camps in the mainland, but Nisei volunteerism soars regardless. Less than 1% of the Japanese population of Hawaii is detained. Japanese bank assets are taken, including Douglas Wada’s father’s savings.

Part 6, Chapter 12 Summary: “Alexander Young Hotel”

Wada learns that an all-Nisei unit is being created in the form of the 100th Infantry. They are shipped to California, then on to training in Wisconsin in high morale.

Part 6, Chapter 13 Summary: “Hotel Pennsylvania”

On June 4, the US Navy took revenge for Pearl Harbor on the Japanese fleet as it positioned to attack Midway. Communications that were captured, deciphered and translated revealed the Japanese attack. The Japanese prisoners from the consulate in Hawaii are being returned in a prisoner exchange aboard a mercy ship, and Yoshikawa is eager to get home. In exchange, the Allies get 1,554 civilians from Asia. The spies who made possible the attack on Pearl Harbor have been set free.

Parts 5-6 Analysis

Since the beginning, Ghosts of Honolulu: A Japanese Spy, A Japanese-American Spy Hunter, and the Untold Story of Pearl Harbor has portrayed the Nisei population as fiercely loyal to the United States: a group willing to enlist in the Armed Forces, to work with the local police, to participate in “English Only” campaigns, and to monitor their Issei neighbors, relatives, and friends. Nevertheless, and despite the preponderance of evidence from trusted sources in the FBI, Navy, and Army, the Roosevelt administration quickly moves to detain members of the Japanese-American community. The book portrays this as a result of the sensationalism of the few Japanese spy rings uncovered in the mainland. The most notable includes a former aide to Charlie Chaplin, raising fears that Hollywood is awash in spies, saboteurs, and fifth-columnists. News sells, but nothing sells better than a celebrity-linked spy story: “What the American public hears is a perfect scandal. There are spies, double agents, lurking subversives, and behind it all are the drumbeats of possible war. But it also involves the world’s largest movie star” (74). The story goes viral, igniting hysteria. Against this setting, it is no wonder Ringle’s report on the real fear behind the hysteria is lost. His assessment is that racial bias lies at the heart of why the Japanese are being treated differently from the German and Italian populations in the United States.

Racial bias is mentioned only once in Ghosts of Honolulu: A Japanese Spy, A Japanese-American Spy Hunter, and the Untold Story of Pearl Harbor. Ringle makes the connection between Japanese incarceration and US racial bias in his report in early 1942. However, it is not until 1988 with the signing of the Civil Liberties Act that President Reagan admits that, “race prejudice, war hysteria and a failure of political leadership” were the primary reasons the Japanese were incarcerated en masse (“Civil Liberties Act of 1988.” Congress.gov). Ghosts of Honolulu: A Japanese Spy, A Japanese-American Spy Hunter, and the Untold Story of Pearl Harbor draws a different conclusion, arguing that it is simply a failure of political leadership to listen to and value subordinate reporting that leads to the incarceration of the Japanese. Given that the book is meant to highlight one intelligence agent’s efforts on the eve of war in an organization that is the precursor to the NCIS, it is understandable that analysis is confined the realm of intelligence collection and the hurdles faced by operatives eager to have their intel read by administration officials.

In light of the undercurrent of racial bias in the 1940s, Douglas Wada’s presence in the ONI and his extensive contributions fighting America’s foes stand out as brave and pioneering. While Wada struggles with issues of identity and belonging at home and among his community, he returns to work every day motivated to protect American national security. This leaves Wada segregated from his peers, something he laments with the Army’s only Japanese American intelligence officer, Iwai. Through Wada, the book explores the theme The Nisei Struggle to Assert Selfhood; it reflects on identity and how one sees oneself in the context of nationalism, ethnicity, and family: Wada lives one life as a spy and soldier and another as a man who belongs to a group that is being illegal incarcerated.

Parts 5 and 6 deal directly with the attack on Pearl Harbor from the vantage point of Douglas Wada and others on that fateful day. The attack on Pearl Harbor results in devastating loss of life and military assets, and leads the US toward the eventual incarceration of the Japanese resident and Japanese American population on American soil without due process. The staggering number of instances in which the intelligence community in Hawaii came close to uncovering the surprise attack highlights the good work of the intelligence operatives working with limited resources, against popular opinion, and without mainland buy-in. At the same time, the book details the exploits of the Japanese spy Yoshikawa, who faces few hurdles and no restrictions of movement while in Hawaii. He is able to walk onto military bases, photograph ships from the harbor, and is not surveilled when leaving the consulate. The book does not explain why Yoshikawa and others at the consulate were not followed or monitored after their arrival in Hawaii. The intelligence community in Hawaii is unanimous in its estimation that the Japanese consulates harbor spies that intended harm to the United States. Ghosts of Honolulu: A Japanese Spy, A Japanese-American Spy Hunter, and the Untold Story of Pearl Harbor does not explain why these agencies leave the spies with full, unrestricted mobility in Hawaii. Intelligence collection is confined almost exclusively to signals intelligence, gathered clandestinely. Human intelligence and surveillance measures are not deployed. Similarly, once arrests are made at the consulate after the attack, local Hawaiian-born Japanese who staff the non-diplomatic positions willingly offered details on the spies among them. The book does not explain why these valuable sources of intelligence are not exploited despite extensive reports and unanimous consensus regarding the spies in the consulate. In this way, the book begins laying the groundwork for a central theme concerning The Lack of Justice at the War’s End.

blurred text
blurred text
blurred text
blurred text