73 pages • 2 hours read
Blaine HardenA modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.
Shin was preparing for school one day when he was summoned by his teacher. Some uniformed men subsequently took him to an office in an underground prison, where he was interrogated by a military officer, much to his confusion. When the officer stated that Shin’s mother and brother had been caught trying to escape, Shin insisted that he knew nothing of their plans.
This was the story that Shin told when he arrived in South Korea and was interviewed by the government’s National Intelligence Service, along with psychiatrists, human rights activists, other defectors, and national and international news media. There was no one around to support or refute his story, and the North Korean government denied the camps’ existence. However, while being interviewed for this book, Shin revealed that he had lied about his brother’s attempted escape. Lying was natural to him while he was in the camp, but he had since realized the value afforded to honesty in the outside world. He also came to feel guilty about his actions, but as he has tried to explain, the camp had its own rules and values that shaped—or warped—his character.
The day before his interrogation, Shin had been told that he did not have to spend the night in the dormitory but could go home and join his mother for supper. The teacher was rewarding him for good behavior, as, by this point, Shin had become tougher, less of an idler, and a frequent informer. When he arrived home, Shin was surprised to see his brother, whom he assumed must have done something good to have been granted this privilege.
After supper, Shin went to sleep in the bedroom; however, he was woken by the sound of his mother and brother talking in the kitchen. He peered through the door and was annoyed to see that his mother was cooking rice whereas she had only given him watery corn soup for supper. In North Korean culture, rice is highly important—it signifies wealth and the closeness of family, and it sanctified a proper meal. Rice was rarely eaten in the camps and was a rare commodity for many North Koreans.
Listening in, Shin learns that his brother had not been given the day off; instead, he had walked away from the factory where he worked after having done something wrong. His mother was consequently helping him escape, even though she knew that both she and other members of the family would be tortured and probably killed as a result. Hearing this, Shin is both angry and afraid, and the instinct to inform takes hold. As it was night time, he is not sure who to tell. He goes to the dormitory to ask advice from his friend, Hong Sung Jo, and the two of them seek out the school’s night guard. Upon reaching his office, Shin realizes that he can profit from the information in his possession. He therefore demands to be given better food and elevated to the position of grade leader at school, which means less work and fewer beatings. The guard agrees to this exchange, and Shin reveals what his mother and brother are planning.
As he wrote in his memoir, Shin was taken to the underground prison the next morning. However, the truth is that he knew why he had been summoned.
During his interrogation, Shin was confused as to why he was not being treated as a dutiful informer—only later did he realize that the night guard had taken credit for discovering the escape plan. As it was, Shin was in a state of shock and unable to say anything coherent. The officer placed a family rap sheet in front of him and told him to affix his thumbprint to the bottom. Again, Shin did not immediately understand what he was seeing, but the papers revealed why his father’s family had been incarcerated: his father was the brother of two men who fled south during a war that devastated most of the Korean peninsula.
Shin was then led to cell in which he spent the night, and the next day, he was brought to an interrogation room. The guards asked him why his family wanted to escape, but he replied that he did not know. On the third day, he was hung upside down in his cell until the guards returned in the evening, and on the fourth day, he was marched to a dimly lit room containing various torture implements. The main interrogator said that he would spare Shin in exchange for the truth, but Shin maintained that he knew nothing. He was consequently stripped, tied to a winch suspended from the ceiling, and tortured until he lost consciousness.
Shin awoke in his cell and, over the next two days, his wounds became infected and he struggled to eat or move. Shin believes that around ten days passed before his final interrogation, which took place in his cell on account of his weakness. This time, however, he was no longer afraid. He insisted that he was the one who reported what his mother and brother were planning, and he begged his interrogators to talk to Hong Sung Jo to confirm this.
After several days, Shin was taken to a cell containing another prisoner. He had been given a reprieve because his classmate had confirmed his story. The night guard, meanwhile, was never seen again.
This section deals with Shin’s arrest and punishment after his brother was caught plotting to escape the camp with help from his mother. Shin’s initial account of these events was not entirely honest: he claimed that he did not know about these plans when, really, he was the one who informed the camp’s night guard about the matter.
Shin’s act of betrayal was instinctive and he had no misgivings about being disloyal to his family. This was all he knew at the time, but, since then, he has realized the importance attached to family in the outside world. This prompted his guilt and his attempt to pretend that he knew nothing of his mother and brother’s plans. He has since revealed the truth, as he has come to realize that honesty is another quality valued in the world outside the camp.
Though Shin was the one who informed on his family members, the night guard’s deceit meant that he was punished and Shin’s confusion about being questioned was genuine. Having acted as an informer, he expected to be rewarded for good behavior. It was only later that he realized that the night guard had taken credit for foiling the escape attempt. This turn of events is not surprising, as every individual within the camp was encouraged to be self-serving. It was thus only natural that the night guard would look out for his own interests at Shin’s expense.
This section also reiterates the importance of food in the camp, with Shin’s resentment having been piqued by the sight of his mother cooking rice for his brother. As Shin was constantly hungry and his mother had only given him watery soup, he saw this as a slap in the face. Here, the author emphasizes the importance of rice in North Korea, noting that it is signifies wealth and the closeness of family. Rice may be seen as a basic food source in other areas of the world, but North Korea is a largely impoverished country and rice is a rare commodity. Shin would not have known about the symbolism of rice, as he was oblivious to the outside world at this point, but what he did know was hunger. His relationship with his mother was already antagonistic, so seeing her cook rice for his brother made him all the more inclined to betray her, as he felt she had betrayed him.
The rest of this section centers on the interrogation and torture to which Shin was subjected in the underground prison. Unaware that Shin was the one who acted as an informer, the guards embarked on a brutal regime of torture, and the book does not shy away from the gory details. Shin’s purpose in recounting these events is to convey the horrors that occur in North Korea’s prison camps, and the visceral descriptions of torture are especially effective in this respect.