logo

73 pages 2 hours read

Blaine Harden

Escape from Camp 14

Nonfiction | Biography | Adult | Published in 2012

A modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.

Chapters 14-16Chapter Summaries & Analyses

Part 2

Chapter 14 Summary

Shin and Park planned to escape through the camp’s gate and then make their way to China, where Park’s uncle would give them shelter and supplies that would aid them as they traveled to South Korea. Shin was scared that Park would sell him out, but his excitement overcame his fear. Their plan was optimistic, even absurd given that only two people other than Shin are known to have escaped these camps and made it to the West. Shin was also plagued with thoughts of what happened to his mother and brother, fearing that he would face the same fate. Still, his mind was now made up.

Shin prepared for his escape by stealing clothes and shoes from a fellow prisoner. He had never done so before, but he had become increasingly intolerant of people who acted as snitches, including the prisoner in question. Escape also meant waiting for an occasion when he and Park were stationed near the fence. This occurred on New Year’s Day, when the factories stopped production for two days. Shin and Park consequently agreed to make their escape on 2nd January, and Shin reluctantly paid his father a visit the day before. Shin was not sure why he felt anger towards his father, who was a victim like himself, but the very fact that his father was alive and attempting reconciliation was enough to arouse an angry response, and Shin remained distant and resentful. His father had encouraged Shin to “‘see what the world is like’” (112), if given the chance. However, this was “lukewarm encouragement” (112); quite possibly because he did not fully trust his son.

There was no special goodbye between Shin and his father, and Shin was conscious that, following his escape, his father would be taken to the underground prison.

Chapter 15 Summary

The following morning, Shin, Park, and around 25 other prisoners were herded up the mountain. Shin and Park had decided to wait until dusk to make their getaway, as their footprints would be more difficult to track in the snow after this time, so they spent the preceding hours working and waiting. During that time, Shin observed that the other workers seemed like cattle and had no awareness that there was a whole other world lying just beyond the fence. He also reflected that he had been similarly oblivious before he met Park.

By late afternoon, Shin could not bear to wait any longer and yelled at Park to run, grabbing his hand and pulling him towards the fence. Park reached the fence first but, as he tried to make his way through the lowest strands of wire, Shin saw sparks and smelled burning flesh. This fence was evidently not the kind that only emitted a brief burst of electricity; rather, it emitted a continuous, lethal current. Shin proceeded to crawl over Park’s body without hesitation, using it as a means of insulation. He incurred severe burns but managed to run for two hours. The problem was that he had he had no idea how to reach China.

Chapter 16 Summary

Happening across a farmer’s shed, Shin found some ears of dried corn and a military uniform. With North Korea being the world’s most militarized society and conscription almost universal, uniforms are everywhere; consequently, by donning this outfit, Shin became just another impoverished, malnourished North Korean. By late evening, he reached the outskirts of a coal town called Bukchang and settled down in a pigpen for the night.

Shin spent the next two days scavenging, yet, despite being hungry and cold, he felt exhilarated by his new freedom. Over the subsequent months and years, he would be advised by therapists, career counselors, preachers, and friends. Through this guidance and his own obsessive reading, he would become familiar with politics, geography, and the basics of Western culture. However, his experiences during these first few days of freedom had a greater effect on him than any of these subsequent teachings. He was shocked to see North Koreans go about their lives without taking orders. That North Korea is viewed by human right groups as the world’s largest prison meant nothing to him, nor did the poverty and gloomy winter conditions. After a life spent in the camp, he felt “wonderfully free” (121).

Entering another unoccupied house, Shin saw a bowl of porridge on the table and gathered that someone would probably be returning soon. He consequently took the food, along with a rucksack and some winter clothes, before venturing out into the center of Bukchang. There, a market lady asked whether he had anything to sell. He told her that he had some rice, which she offered to buy for four thousand North Korean won (around four dollars at black-market exchange rates). He consequently sold the rucksack, though he had no idea whether this was good value.

He spent the day eavesdropping on the conversations of various bedraggled looking men in the city. In a survey of North Korean refugees carried out in China from 2004–2005, it was found that most people wandering around North Korea at that time were unemployed laborers and failed farmers. More than half of the refugees had used cash to bribe officials or buy the help of professional smugglers. After the famine, laws were often ignored and police could be bribed quite easily. Vagabonds could therefore head towards China without attracting attention. While the number of defections to China is unclear, the number of North Koreans seeking asylum in South Korea has increased nearly every year since 1995.

Shin fell in with these vagrants and made his way towards the Chinese border in January 2005. Conditions seem to have been quite favorable at that time, and guards were receptive to bribes. There was also an established smuggling network, with operatives claiming that they could get virtually any North Korean out of the country. The North Korean government has tried to quash these smuggling operations, and has succeeded in some cases. The policy is to execute those helping people to defect, but the most successful brokers have contacts in the military, which helps them to bribe the guards. However, many defectors are so in debt to their smugglers that South Korea’s government had to change how it distributed financial support to refugees. Rather than handing out lump sums, it paid money to individuals who gained and held down jobs. In addition, around a quarter of the money went toward housing so as to prevent it being paid to brokers.

Shin did not have the awareness, money, or contacts to employ professional smugglers, but, by falling in with various traders, he was able to learn how to get by in North Korea’s post-famine economy. Along with these traders, he headed north.

Chapter 14 – Chapter 16 Analysis

Part II focuses on Shin’s escape from the camp. Despite his fear, he convinced himself that the odds of success were good, which was both unrealistic and optimistic. Shin paid his father a visit for the last time, but, as usual, their interactions were stilted and there was no sense of closeness or trust between them. Shin was also aware that, following his escape, his father would be taken to the underground prison and interrogated. In fact, despite his anger towards his mother and brother, Shin’s actions were no different from theirs, in that he was willing to let his father be tortured as a result of his own actions.

Shin and Park made their move in early January 2005 but only Shin was successful. Park’s death by electrocution was an instance of bad luck, and Shin’s use of his dead body as a buffer was instinctive. At that moment, he was like an animal in his need to flee to safety—there was no time to think or to mourn. In later years, however, Shin has come to feel guilty about his behavior. He now knows the value attached to empathy and respect, and the act of using another person’s body as an escape tool flies in the face of such qualities. Nevertheless, on a practical level, this act allowed Shin to survive. Had he hesitated, he may not have lived to tell his story.

The rest of this section focuses on Shin’s actions once he was outside the camp. Park was the one who had formulated the plan to travel to China; likewise, he was the one with knowledge of the outside world. Shin had never set foot outside the camp so he had little choice but to try and get away and find food, clothing, and shelter.

Once he finds a military uniform in a farmer’s shed Shin fits in with the rest of the North Korean populace. Poverty was rife in North Korea, so Shin did not stand out—he was just another poor, malnourished youth. Shin subsequently lived as a vagrant but, despite these unfavorable conditions, he emphasizes the shock he felt at seeing people living their lives freely. Human rights groups may see North Korea as a prison but, after his experience in an actual prison camp, Shin perceived the country in a more favorable light. In fact, Shin refers to these first few days of freedom as having had a greater impact on him that any of his experiences thereafter.

Stealing a rucksack and some rice from a temporarily unoccupied house was another significant episode in Shin’s post-camp life. He had intended to keep the rice for himself but then he was offered money for it by a market lady. Shin knew nothing of the value of money at that point, but he sold the rice nonetheless and thus engaged in a financial exchange for the first time. He subsequently fell in with the numerous unemployed laborers and farmers who were drifting through North Korea at that time, seeking to gain entry into and employment in China. 

blurred text
blurred text
blurred text
blurred text