logo

60 pages 2 hours read

Julie Murphy

Dumplin

Fiction | Novel | YA | Published in 2015

A modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.

Chapters 39-44Chapter Summaries & Analyses

Chapters 39-44 Summary

Willowdean spends time with Mitch. They eat lunch together, play video games, and Will eats dinner at Mitch’s house. Mitch tells Willowdean that his mom wants him to ask Will to Homecoming. Mitch is telling Willowdean how he doesn’t think he can leave town after high school and leave his mom when Will notices Tim walking past them. Will begs Tim to help her win back Ellen’s friendship. Tim says he will try but that he doesn’t think he will be able to do anything to change El’s mind. Then he tells Will that he really hates Callie.

One night at the Chili Bowl, Willowdean’s former boss, Ron, comes to ask Will to come back and work for him: “I may be old, but I’m not dumb. I don’t know what happened, but whatever it was, I promise the boys will be on their best behavior” (218). Willowdean thinks about how nice Ron has been to her and tells him that she will think about it. Thinking about it, Will knows that she made more money at Harpy’s. Knowing that Bo is now with Bekah, she goes to Harpy’s after her shift at the Chili Bowl is over and asks Ron for a raise and for days off in the summer (for the pageant). He agrees, and she agrees to come back to work at Harpy’s.

At her first night back at Harpy’s, Marcus tells Willowdean that Bo almost got fired a couple weeks after Willowdean quit. He said Bo was only allowed to work at Harpy’s if he stayed in the kitchen because when he worked the register, he refused to serve guys who came in from his old school. When Willowdean gets her bag in her locker before going home, she finds a red sucker.

At home, Willowdean’s mother is hemming pageant dresses for Bekah and her friend Lacy. Bekah notices Willowdean’s Harpy’s uniform and mentions that while she hasn’t asked him yet, Bo is going to be her escort for the pageant. About Bo, Lacy says: “He’s a strange one” (225). Willowdean finds out that her mother is doing dress alterations for extra cash and that earlier in the night, Ellen and her mother were at Willowdean’s house. Mrs. Dixon asks Will about Ellen and says that the two girls will work things out, adding: “Me and Luce always did” (226). Willowdean then asks her mother if she ever misses Lucy. Her mother says yes and tells Will she misses Lucy all the time.

On the day of Homecoming, Will comes to school to find a giant mum made by Mitch’s mom on her second period desk. No one has given Willowdean a Homecoming mum before, but Will has to work that night and can’t take off because she is taking days off for the pageant. Will can’t go to the Homecoming dance with Mitch. That night, Callie and her boyfriend go to Harpy’s with Ellen and Tim. At first, Willowdean is upset that they would show up, but then she realizes that Tim set the visit up just like Will asked him to. When Will asks Ellen how she is, Callie tells Ellen that she doesn’t owe anything to Will. Ellen agrees, and they all leave.

Bo tells Willowdean that he is glad that she is back at Harpy’s but sad that she felt the need to leave. They talk some more, but when they leave, Willowdean finds Mitch outside, waiting for her: “It’s horrible of me, but I resent him being here. I’m like one of those people who doesn’t like for their food touch. I need for Mitch to stay on his side of the plate” (233).

Will goes trick or treating with Mitch after work. After, they lay in the grass talking and Mitch kisses Will. Will admits to herself that she doesn’t feel with Mitch what she felt with Bo. Bo sends Will a text message saying that he is glad that she is back.

Because the dress that Willowdean’s mother has worn every year since she won the pageant no longer fits, she tells Will that she will be fasting until the pageant. She will also go to Pilates every night, so Will can no longer have the car in the evenings. Her mother is supposed to pick her up at work, but Mrs. Dixon falls asleep and doesn’t show up until Will calls to remind her of the driving arrangement. Bo agrees to wait with Will until her mother shows up. They sit in Bo’s truck and talk while they wait.

Willowdean references that Bo’s family has a lot of money because he went to private school, and he snaps at her for the assumption. Bo had a basketball scholarship to the school, but Willowdean never knew this. As she gets into her mother’s car, her mother talks to Bo. Bo tells Will’s mother that he can drive Will to and from work every day.

The next day, in World History, Bo sits in Amanda’s seat next to Willowdean. He continues to sit there for the rest of the week. At work, he whistles “Jolene” as he cooks in the kitchen, which turns Willowdean’s knees “to mush” (250). As he drives Will home, Bo tells her about losing his basketball scholarship to private school because he hurt his knee and then got into a physical fight with one of his classmates.

When Willowdean admits she has no talent for the pageant’s talent show, Mitch gives her a magic book. Willowdean doesn’t like the idea of performing magic tricks but figures she has no other choice. 

Chapters 39-44 Analysis

When Willowdean returns to Harpy’s, she compares it to comfort food because she feels more comfortable working for Ron with Marcus and Bo than she did when she worked at the Chili Bowl. When she works with Bo, she can’t help but notice Bo staring at her: “I walk to my car as Bo’s gaze follows me; the feeling of it starts as a ball of heat in my chest and spreads like a sunrise” (106). Will still has feelings for Bo.

Will also still misses her friendship with Ellen. She composes texts to Ellen but doesn’t send them. She is hurt when she finds out that Ellen was out her house as Will’s mom hemmed Ellen’s pageant dress. This makes Will feel like Ellen, Mrs. Dryver, and Mrs. Dixon share something together that Will does not. Will feels like an outsider.

It is in these chapters that we start to see how Willowdean really feels about Mitch. When Mitch spills his heart out to Will about leaving his mom after high school, Will, consumed with her own life, leaves Mitch to talk to Tim about Ellen. In this sense, Will is not regarding Mitch as a person of value, despite his continued support and kindness. While Will judges Ellen for her lack of true friendship, Will demonstrates that she herself is not the person of integrity she believes herself to be.

In Texas, it is a tradition for guys to give a mum to their Homecoming date. Homecoming is considered a celebration, and the mum represents this. Girls wear their homecoming mums all day. When Mitch gives Willowdean a homecoming mum, she doesn’t take it off:

I wear the mum all day long. It’s so big I have to wear it around my neck. Hannah and Amanda make fun of me. Millie thinks it’s adorable. But by the end of the day, my neck is sore and my shoulders are hunched from the weight of it (229).

Eventually, the mum feels like it an incredible weight that holds Willowdean down, just as Mitch is a proverbial weight that holds Willowdean back from pursuing what she wants. While she is happy to be back at Harpy’s, Willowdean is still self-deprecating around Bo. When Bo tells Willowdean that he can’t hear Dolly Parton without thinking about her, Willowdean says that it is good that no one plays Dolly Parton on the radio anymore.

Willowdean is still dreading the talent show portion of the pageant and compares herself to Bekah, wishing that she too had a natural talent. Willowdean tries to learn magic tricks with the magic trick book that Mitch gives her, but she thinks that the magic tricks feel “like settling” (255). This parallels how Willowdean feels about Mitch. When comparing Mitch to Bo, Willowdean feels like she is “settling” with a partner which whom she believes society is more accepting of based on his husky stature. This sentiment is mirrored in Patrick's earlier comment that Mitch found someone his size. These jabs reinforce to Will that she is not suited to be with someone as handsome as Bo, and therefore must only strive for attainable relationships and goals. However, as Will breaks the limitations that she believes society has placed on her, such as taking part in the pageant, she accepts that she has, in fact, been the one limiting herself.

blurred text
blurred text
blurred text
blurred text