62 pages • 2 hours read
Marian HaleA modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.
Mama runs down to meet Seth when he returns. Everyone gathers around so he can tell them what happened. Seth updates them about his father’s choice to rebuild the bridge and passes on Papa’s message to Mama. Aunt Julia asks for news; Seth apologizes and tells her he’ll search again in the morning. Aunt Julia tells him no more searching. Seth goes outside to see Ezra’s progress on the new outhouse. He asks Ezra about Aunt Julia, Andy, and Will; Ezra says they’ll all be alright and tells Seth he’s going to build the boys a new treehouse.
Andy and Will ask Seth to tell them what he thinks happened to their father (Uncle Nate) and Ben. Seth tells them he thinks Nate and Ben worked hard to save the business but may have stayed too late. He tells them it’s possible the men drowned. The boys say that because their bodies weren’t found yet, they may be safe somewhere else. All three agree not to give up hope. The boys thank Seth for his honesty. Seth notices Aunt Julia is just inside and must have overheard.
That evening, Seth takes Matt to the rail yard. He wishes he could protect Matt from the trauma of seeing the bodies, wreckage, and searching for survivors. They find Papa working. Seth tells Papa Josiah was captured by the body gangs. Papa seems upset by this, which surprises Seth. Papa tells Seth he better start heading home before it gets dark. He asks if Seth passed on his message to Mama; Seth confirms it bitterly. As he walks home, he wonders why the message is so important to Papa.
On Tuesday morning, Seth wakes to find that Lucas, Andy, and Will all joined him in bed. Seth worries about Josiah, thinking the other boy will probably be haunted by what he had to do on the barge. Mama made pan bread for breakfast. Mama and Seth talk about what a good, helpful man Ezra is. Mama calls Ezra “smart” and says he “sure deserves more than his lot in life” (161-62). She asks if Seth and Josiah could rebuild Ezra’s little house in the backyard. Seth says he'll put it on his list but that Aunt Julia’s house is the priority and they need to repair the roof before the next rain. Mama says Papa would be proud of him. Seth is still angry with his father for joining the bridge crew instead of coming home to help.
Outside, Seth carves Sarah Louise Ellington’s name into a wooden marker and wedges it into the branches of the magnolia tree. He hears Ella Rose singing nursery rhymes with the young children; he thinks he was seeing a darkness in her since the loss of her father, but her voice sounds happy now. Matt comes back to help the boys haul ruined carpets and furniture from the house. He tells them the men are working around the clock at the bridge to repair it and that it might take a while. Seth has already accepted this and is starting to think he can handle matters at home by himself after all.
Seth sees Ella Rose staring at the lot where her house was. Now he knows there is a darkness growing in her. Ezra finishes the outhouse and then helps Seth work on the roof. Ezra goes for more fresh water at midday; Seth notices how tired the man is and knows he worked since it was dark that morning, so he thinks he will have to make sure Ezra rests.
Seth sees Josiah walking down the street with Henry Covington. He calls for Ella Rose, who is overjoyed to see her cousin alive. Henry tells her only he and his younger brother, Spencer, survived. Josiah and Seth push Henry’s wagon, which is full of food supplies, to the backyard. Seth wishes he could help Josiah, but he knows the other boy saw awful things and needs to process them. Ella Rose tries to bring Henry and Josiah into the house, but Josiah says he must clean up first. Ella Rose tells him she’ll send someone out with strong soap and clean clothes. Seth appreciates how gentle and caring she is with Josiah.
Ezra is very relieved to see Josiah. Henry leaves to help rebuild the house of the Dobsons, who’d sheltered him and Spencer during the storm. Henry asks Ella Rose to come with him, but she says she owes a debt to the Braedens and will stay and help with the children. Henry asks Seth to walk with him; he tells Seth about finding Mr. Farrell’s body in a tree on Sunday morning. Henry also tells Seth the Judsons and their house are gone and that the burial at sea failed—even with the weights, hundreds of bodies washed up on shore that morning. They’re burning the bodies now. Henry says everyone is worried about disease spreading if they don’t take care of the bodies. He says he’s telling Seth so he can find a way to tell the women.
Seth finishes fixing the roof, then finds his mother and tells her about the bodies washing ashore and the burn pile. They decide they will tell Aunt Julia together after supper. They realize they’ll have to warn Matt, too, because he’ll probably see the burning bodies when he’s taking Papa his meals that night. Seth offers to go instead of Matt to spare him, but Mama says Seth is needed at the house. After supper, Mama and Seth tell Aunt Julia the news. She maintains her composure. That night, Seth and Josiah sit on the roof and watch the sky and the dozen or more fires.
Mama finds the board with Sarah Louise’s name carved on it and convinces Seth to tell her what happened. She makes a paper flower and attaches it to the board. The days blur together as the family works hard to repair the house. The newspapers continue to list the dead, but the family does not report Nate and Ben as among them. On Wednesday evening, the city water mains re-open, and everyone celebrates. That evening, Uncle Nate’s horse, Archer, wanders back into the yard. He serves as a symbol of hope that Ben and Nate and even Henry’s family might still find their way home.
On Thursday, the newspaper prints a full accounting of the storm. The telegraph office opens. On Friday, the banks open, too. The temperatures hit 100 degrees, but no one dares to enter the gulf to swim for relief. No one eats fish from the gulf, either: Seth explains, “As long as the dead still washed ashore, the gulf would remain an unclean enemy” (179). Ezra makes all the trips to pick up rations in town; he’s afraid the militia might press Josiah into service or mistake him for a looter. Provisions start to arrive from the mainland. There are rumors more than 5,000 people died on the night of the storm.
On Saturday, one week after the storm, Matt comes home late and upset. He tells Seth he let Papa sleep later than he was supposed to and that Papa swore at him for it. Seth consoles him and sends him off to finish up the tree fort with the other boys. The family finally has clean water, so Mama and Aunt Julia work on scrubbing the grime from the house and the family’s clothes. Seth worries for Ella Rose, who rarely smiles anymore. He thinks her loss might be overwhelming her. Then he wonders if she’s sad because Seth is too busy to spend time with her.
Seth and Josiah work to repair the house. Seth is anxious about his father coming home and finding his work inadequate. Ezra comes home with news that mule carts will begin running their routes again. Everyone is excited for this small return to normal life. Seth worries about Josiah’s mental health after all the other boys saw on the body gangs. Seth tells Josiah they need to go out looking for a lot more lumber the next day so they can rebuild Ezra and Josiah’s house. Josiah smiles and agrees. They watch the twilight sky together until supper is ready.
Everyone gets a tub bath that night. Seth gets into a clean bed and feels almost like life is normal again. He thinks about Ella Rose and wonders if she ever lies awake thinking of him. On Sunday morning the convent bells ring, but only a few of the city’s churches can hold services. Mama asks Seth to read some Bible verses to the family before breakfast but doesn’t ask them to observe the day by not working.
Seth and Josiah build a sled and take Archer out to find lumber to rebuild Ezra’s house. The house will be small and simple, but Seth wants to add a little porch area where Ezra can sit and watch his garden. On Monday morning, Seth awakens from a dream about Zach. He and Josiah work on the foundation to Ezra’s house after breakfast, even though they need more lumber. When Matt gets home, he surprises Seth by hooking up the sled to the horse and getting the younger boys to help him find lumber. They even find four windows.
The newspaper reports the number of dead might rise to 6,000. The number is staggering, but Seth thinks it may match the level of devastation he saw on his travels. Some stores in town regain power. Support pours in from around the country—the American Red Cross arrives, and contributions begin to arrive from people all over. Seth is thankful but also wishes they could just leave. Many people already left the island, but Seth knows his family will stay: “The storm that ravaged Galveston had left behind much more than wreckage and mud and death. It had left a challenge” (190). Josiah and Seth build a bond as they work together. They discuss how they only ever felt such peace working with another man when they were working with Zach.
In this section of the novel, the rebuilding begins. Despite limited resources, the family rallies together and works hard to restore Aunt Julia’s home. Papa has chosen to work on the bridge, a decision that Seth resented, but his absence creates space for Seth to step up and act like the adult he’s been wanting to be recognized as. Seth feels anxious about his father’s inevitable judgment, worrying that no matter how hard he works, what he does won’t be good enough for his father. Seth thinks of Zach often during these days, remembering the man as something of an icon, the symbolic “true carpenter” that Seth believes himself to be. Seth’s language when he thinks of Zach is akin to that of self-discovery or an awakening:
I woke before daylight Monday morning and realized that I’d been dreaming of Zach. I’d been working with him again, side by side, drawn into that mystifying current of his. I lay perfectly still, breathing in the wonder of that, trying to hang on to the connection, that simple truth that ran like a river between us (188).
The “mystifying current” that connects them is a love of carpentry, of working with their hands, of shaping wood and metal into something functional and beautiful. Seth aspires to be like Zach and hopes that his father will be able recognize him as a “true carpenter” and accept his decision not to go to college. This speaks to The Contribution of Different Forms of Labor to the Community, as Seth’s specific contribution is emphasized here. Everyone in this community has labor that can be contributed and that is all equal, and the text emphasizes that certain kinds of labor are for some people while other kinds are for other people. These chapters point to Seth’s unique contribution, as a carpenter who wants to rebuild the city with his hands.
The trauma of the storm continues as horrific news reaches Seth, highlighting Individual and Collective Trauma and Healing. The failure of the mass water burial is particularly gruesome, as is the image of hundreds of bodies washing up on shore. Like Aunt Julia and Ella Rose, Seth buries his feelings of grief and horror. Some of his trauma is relieved when he shares the story of Sarah Louise with his mother. Despite Seth’s own trauma, he spends much of his time worrying about protecting or consoling others from the trauma they’ve faced. He is particularly concerned about Josiah, who he knows saw horrible things during his time on the barge crew. He is also deeply worried about Ella Rose, in whom he sees a “darkness” rising as she processes her grief. As the “man of the house,” Seth takes on these worries as his own and works to protect the others as much as he can. For example, Seth offers to take Papa’s meals so that Matt won’t have to walk by the piles of burning bodies, is careful not to remind Josiah of his night on the barge, and watches and consoles Ella Rose when her emotions overwhelm her. Though he is meant to be stepping into his father’s shoes around the house, Seth fulfills the role of an adult in his own, compassionate way. Seth is attentive to the feelings of his family and takes proactive steps to ease their pain. These chapters demonstrate the individual trauma experienced by each person that converges to become a larger, collective trauma. Seth grows as a character by recognizing these traumas in others and attempting to help contribute to collective healing. It will require everyone joining together to collectively heal from their collective trauma.
Seth and Josiah’s friendship develops as they work hard together to rebuild. Seth’s care for Josiah and Ezra is shown through his plan to add a small porch to Ezra’s house so that the man can overlook his new garden, something Seth knows is important to him. Ezra is similarly thoughtful about the younger boys in the family—he prioritizes rebuilding the tree house to give the boys some joy, telling Seth, “Busy hands can sometimes help heal lonesome hearts” (154). Seth later tells his mother, “He thinks that giving the boys something fun to do will help with Andy and Will’s grieving,” to which Seth’s mother responds that Ezra, “sure deserves more than his lot in life” (161-62). This exchange shows that Seth and his mother are able to acknowledge Ezra’s humanity in a way that society doesn’t. Further, Seth’s awareness of Josiah and Ezra’s need for a space of their own shows that he does not see the men as “lesser” the way many other white people of the time do. The contrast between Seth’s treatment of Josiah and the reality of the time shows the depths of Systemic Racism Even Amid Tragedy that Black people face. Even though Seth and some of his family attempt to treat Ezra and Josiah as equals, society as a whole continues to oppress them, showing that even in this time of tragedy and collective healing, Black people are excluded.