46 pages • 1 hour read
Julia PhillipsA modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.
Summary
Background
Chapter Summaries & Analyses
Character Analysis
Themes
Symbols & Motifs
Important Quotes
Essay Topics
Tools
As the novel’s title suggests, the significance of the bear is central. Like other symbols in the novel, its meaning shifts and evolves. Initially, it’s a magical anomaly for both Elena and Sam, infusing their mundane lives with excitement. The bear continues to have this effect on Elena as she spots the bear multiple times. She quickly adopts the belief that the bear is magical—that it deliberately chose to show itself to her because she’s special and unique. In this way, the bear has an uplifting effect on Elena, validating her as a person in ways that her family and those around her can’t. Elena becomes so convinced of the bear’s magical qualities that she denies the bear’s ability to harm her. Her increasing number of safe encounters with it only strengthens her resolve, further distancing her from rational thought and behavior.
More importantly, the bear symbolizes a growing chasm in the strong bond between the sisters. Because they don’t agree on whether the bear is safe to be around, Sam and Elena are at odds. Elena doesn’t want to relinquish the thing that has brought new meaning to her life, while Sam fears that the bear will harm Elena. The bear symbolically takes Sam’s place as an entity of great significance in Elena’s life. Sam tries to convince Elena that she doesn’t need the bear in her life—in other words, that their friendship and bond can sustain Elena and continue to provide her with the fulfillment she longs for.
The bear’s death brings about the end of the threat to Sam’s safety only at the cost of Elena’s life: the very thing that Sam, ironically, sought to preserve.
San Juan island, the sisters’ home, contains seemingly contradictory meaning for Sam. Early in the novel, she laments the lack of jobs on the island. Though she tried to gain a foothold in obtaining one of the more lucrative ones by earning merchant mariner certification, she never receives an interview for a position. This suggests that on the island, as in other places in the world, some have unfair advantages. Thus, the women are trapped in a dead-end situation, kept out of reach of the opportunity to build better their lives in the same way that the land mass of the island is separated from the mainland. Sam comes to regard the island as an enemy, a thing that traps her in a depressing, difficult life. She grows to dislike—and feel disdain toward—the tourists that flock to the island, finding its remoteness exhilarating and exotic. The tourists, unlike Sam, are free to leave, and thus the island represents an enchanted, otherworldliness to them rather than a prison.
Nevertheless, Sam clings to the pleasant memories of her childhood in which the island figured prominently. She notes its natural beauty: its lush vegetation, peaceful forests, clear waters, and abundant wildlife. When she recalls her idyllic childhood, the island’s connotations shift to much happier ones for Sam. She’s certain that when she has the chance to leave the island, she’ll maintain this positive image of it in her mind.
The house, which the sisters’ late grandmother purchased in 1979, has a shifting meaning as the novel progresses. Being able to afford the house was a source of pride for their grandmother, symbolizing the family’s incremental climb toward middle-class status. Owning a home symbolized success and proved that the family was financially stable and secure. As the only house that the sisters have ever lived in, it represents the love of their mother and grandmother and their strong familial bond. When their mother recalls how her mother, the sisters’ grandmother, died in the house, Sam understands how the house is a kind of cornerstone in their family legacy: Their mother also dies there, reinforcing how traditions—both good and painful ones—pass down through the generations. The house is a safe haven from the outside world, protecting the sisters and their mother protected from those who, in Sam’s estimation, don’t understand them or could cause them harm. When their mother’s abusive boyfriend temporarily lived there, his presence symbolically tarnished the house, making it unsafe for a time.
Sam points out the ways in which the house is currently in poor physical condition; it needs repairs that the family can’t afford. However, because the land on which it sits is coveted, it contains untapped value and potential. Therefore, Sam regards selling the house as the key to a better life: When the house is sold, she and Elena can afford to leave the island and obtain better jobs, thus improving their lives overall. Ironically, this can’t occur until their mother’s death. However, Elena eventually discloses to Sam that she had to take out a second mortgage on the house and that it’s thus no longer a source of untapped wealth for them. She also reveals that she doesn’t—and never truly did—share Sam’s dream of leaving the island, viewing it as a futile, unrealistic goal. To Elena, the house became a burden—an additional drain on their finances.
Animals in Literature
View Collection
Appearance Versus Reality
View Collection
Beauty
View Collection
Books on Justice & Injustice
View Collection
Canadian Literature
View Collection
Community
View Collection
Family
View Collection
Fate
View Collection
Fear
View Collection
Friendship
View Collection
Good & Evil
View Collection
Grief
View Collection
Guilt
View Collection
Memory
View Collection
Mortality & Death
View Collection
Mothers
View Collection
Romance
View Collection
Safety & Danger
View Collection
Trust & Doubt
View Collection
Truth & Lies
View Collection
Valentine's Day Reads: The Theme of Love
View Collection