49 pages • 1 hour read
Julia QuinnAn Offer From a Gentleman
Fiction | Novel | Adult | Published in 2001A modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.
Part 2, Chapter 19-Second EpilogueChapter Summaries & Analyses
Part 2, Chapter 19 Summary
Lady Whistledown notes that Miss Posy Reiling seemed to be searching for someone at her mother’s musicale. Benedict interrupts his mother’s lecture on eligible maidens to ask about when she met his father. Lady Bridgerton says that she’d always scoffed at the notion of love at first sight, but she knew the first time she spoke with him that he was her husband-to-be. Benedict feels jealous that his parents knew true love. He asks what he should do if he falls in love with someone not of their social class, and Violet responds that she loves her son and would support him. Benedict realizes from their conversation that his mother had been a wallflower, which explains her sympathy for girls like Penelope Featherington.
Benedict realizes that he loves Sophie. He goes to look for her and finds her in the nursery with Hyacinth and the cousins. They are playing blind man’s bluff, and Sophie, as the blind man in the game, is wearing a scarf over her eyes. When Benedict sees her, he recognizes that she is the woman he met at the masquerade ball. He is angry that she has not told him her identity and accuses her of withholding that information. Sophie says that she had no choice but to disappear. She admits to herself that perhaps she hadn’t told him the truth out of pride because he didn’t recognize her, but she also feared that telling him would lead to a broken heart, as the dreams of a servant don’t usually come true. She admits her background as the Earl of Penwood’s illegitimate daughter. He is so angry that he fears he might hurt her, so he leaves the room.
Part 2, Chapter 20 Summary
Lady Whistledown reports on Lady Penwood’s ill temper. Sophie packs her bag. She has felt accepted in the Bridgerton family and aches to leave them. She blames her father for sheltering her when she was young and giving her dreams that can never come true—not now that she is a servant. She wants to cry because Benedict has “broken her heart twice—once by asking her to be his mistress, and once by making her love his family and then forcing her to leave” (351). Manners dictate that she tenders her resignation to Lady Bridgerton, who says that she knows Sophie’s character and that she is the sort of woman she’d want for Benedict. Sophie thanks Lady Bridgerton for her kindness. Lady Bridgerton insists that Sophie leave in the Bridgerton carriage, and while Lady Bridgerton makes arrangements, Sophie steps outside. Araminta spots her and shrieks for a constable, accusing Sophie of being a thief. Sophie runs, but a bystander tackles her. The authorities take her to jail.
Part 2, Chapter 21 Summary
Lady Whistledown reports that Penelope Featherington was seen in the company of three Bridgerton brothers on the steps of Lady Bridgerton’s house. Later in the day, a maid was arrested for theft, the penalty for which is either hanging or transportation. The next morning, Benedict fences with his brother Colin. Colin says that Benedict should simply marry Sophie, as no one who matters will care if Benedict marries a maid. Benedict realizes that he has not respected Sophie’s choices. He knows that if he marries her, they likely will be rejected by certain elements of London’s ton, but he would not mind a quiet life in the country with Sophie. Benedict realizes that his brother is maturing into a perceptive man. He goes to find Sophie, but Lady Bridgerton does not know where she went. Francesa and Hyacinth have read Lady Whistledown’s column, and they guess that Sophie was taken to jail. When Benedict thinks that his mother shouldn’t come, Lady Bridgerton retorts, “I’m hardly a wilting flower” (372).
Part 2, Chapter 22 Summary
Lady Whistledown reports that shortly after Lady Bridgerton and Benedict departed their house in haste, Lady Penwood and Posy had a public row outside their house. Sophie is cold in jail, and she dislikes the rats. Araminta visits, saying that she will claim that Sophie stole her shoe clips and her wedding ring. Sophie asks why Araminta hates her, and Araminta replies that it is because the Earl of Penwood loved her. Sophie objects that her father never showed her love. Araminta admits that she felt jealous and humiliated because she could not bear Penwood an heir; Sophie was perpetual proof of her failure.
Araminta taunts Sophie about what her life will be like in Australia, but Benedict appears and interrupts her. Sophie is overjoyed that he came for her. Lady Bridgerton and the magistrate also arrive. Benedict announces that Sophie is his fiancée and attacks Lady Penwood when she calls Sophie a “whore.” Benedict tells Araminta that she stole Sophie’s childhood. When Araminta repeats her claims of theft, Posy appears and, in a comic moment, declares that she, Posy, stole Araminta’s shoe clips. Sophie tries to speak up on Posy’s behalf, but Posy silences her. Araminta disowns Posy for betraying her, and Lady Bridgerton offers for Posy to visit her indefinitely. Sophie explains to the magistrate how Araminta made her a lady’s maid instead of supporting her as the Earl of Penwood asked. Posy further reveals that the earl left a dowry for Sophie, which Lady Bridgerton suspects Araminta stole.
Part 2, Chapter 23 Summary
Lady Bridgerton compels Araminta to pretend that Sophie was the Earl of Penwood’s ward, the “legitimate” child of the earl’s friend, Charles Beckett. Araminta declares that if Posy leaves with Lady Bridgerton, she is dead to her mother. Lady Bridgerton promises Posy that she has a home with them. Sophie, angered, punches Lady Penwood in the face and says that the blow is “for not loving [her] daughters equally” (398). Benedict tells his mother that he is proud to be her son, and Lady Bridgerton bursts into tears.
Sophie returns to Benedict’s home with him. Benedict renders a tender declaration of his love, saying that Sophie took the time to know him as Benedict, not as “Number Two.” He feels he is a better man when she is near. He offers her a bath, and Sophie feels that she is “beginning the rest of her life” (407). They make love, affirming that they belong to one another. When they wake up later, Sophie wonders if she will now see her name in Lady Whistledown’s column. Benedict muses that one reason he was reluctant to give his heart to Sophie is because he was still hoping to find the lady from the masquerade; she had been his dream.
Epilogue Summary
It is April 9, 1824. Lady Whistledown reports that the Bridgerton family is gathering to celebrate Lady Bridgerton’s birthday with a ball. Sophie and Benedict have been married for seven years and have three sons. Sophie has been mentioned in Lady Whistledown’s column 232 times. Sophie is expecting again, and they hope for a girl they will name Violet. Lady Whistledown puts down her pen and muses that it is time for something new.
Second Epilogue Summary
Posy is 25 and considered a “spinster.” Sophie speculates with Benedict about whom Posy might marry. Benedict suggests the new rector, Mr. Woodson. Posy, who has been living with Lady Bridgerton, comes to visit Sophie at her country home. Sophie introduces Posy to Mr. Woodson, and it is love at first sight for both. Sophie and Benedict are glad for them. Posy has five children, and the last is a girl she names Minty.
Part 2, Chapter 19-Second Epilogue Analysis
The third-act breakup is a frequent feature of a romance story. Under the assumption that the dramatic action of the plot can be broken into three acts, the third act includes an episode of conflict that drives the romantic leads apart and makes it appear that reconciliation is impossible. Authors generally introduce this episode after the leads are united in their love and create an obstacle that, once overcome, will bring them firmly together.
The breakup here begins with an internal conflict when Benedict has his long-awaited moment of recognition and finally realizes that Sophie is the mystery woman from the masquerade for whom he has been searching. Realizing the truth regarding Hidden Identities and Secret Selves, Benedict rejects her out of hurt and anger that she was not forthright with him; this rejection triggers a larger rift when Sophie, determined to leave the scene of her heartbreak, is taken into custody following Araminta’s accusation of theft. This compounds the blame against her.
Araminta’s accusation is justified, in the strictest sense, as Sophie did steal from her. Penalties for theft in Regency Britain were notoriously severe. However, Araminta’s revenge brings about a larger moment of recognition and reconciliation when Sophie finally clarifies her past before Benedict and Lady Bridgerton. This provides a moment of emotional vulnerability and asserts the truth. Sophie reveals the real circumstances, and they are not simply the facts of her parentage or bloodline; rather, they are the consequences of Araminta’s neglect, rejection, and mistreatment. That Sophie has not become bitter or vengeful from this treatment but has retained the kind and caring nature that Lady Bridgerton noted is a mark of her personality and a further parallel with the Cinderella story. Benedict must truly see Sophie before she can be fully accepted.
Benedict’s character arc and his path toward reconciliation involve accepting Sophie’s choices, and he eventually understands Sophie’s motives in refusing to be his mistress. He sees these as altruistic rather than unkind; she does not want to risk subjecting a child to the same circumstances she grew up in. Part of Sophie’s reveal includes him coming to see things from her perspective. This includes him understanding that Family as a Source of Nurturance or Status, something he has and takes for granted, is precious to her. This final understanding, acknowledgment, and acceptance allows them the final scene of reconciliation and intimacy, where the romantic leads confirm their love for one another and the happy ending is complete.
What further adds to the final resolution is that the characters reconcile Fantasy in Opposition to Reality; Benedict realizes how bound he was to the notion of finding and marrying his mystery lady, which impeded his ability to cherish Sophie, even though she is, ironically, the lady. The novel further reveals hidden identities and secret selves to a smaller extent on Benedict’s part as he shares that Sophie sees him as a distinct person, not purely in relationship to his family. Sophie’s background, once revealed, exonerates her from Araminta’s accusations, as Araminta’s crimes against Sophie are worse. Posy’s sudden decision to stand up for Sophie, despite the repercussions, underlines Quinn’s exploration of secret selves coming to the fore. Letting their true feelings emerge is another way that these characters achieve wholeness and reconciliation.
Social class both is and is not an issue in the final resolution. Benedict’s love for Sophie overcomes her birth, but he recognizes the obstacle that this presents in terms of her acceptance by those of his class. Being from a family of modest means but “legitimate” birth is, in the Bridgerton world, slightly more acceptable than being the “illegitimate” daughter of a nobleman and a servant. As a result, this is the background they fabricate for her. In the highly structured hierarchy of British social class, Benedict expects to be excluded from social activities that the very upper crust hosts. This is why he chooses to live outside of London, where the ton has little sway. While Benedict and the Bridgertons realize that Sophie’s worth as a person is not determined nor influenced by the circumstances of her birth, they are certain that their social class will feel differently. This requires the charade. In this way, while Sophie’s hidden identity is no longer necessary for the Bridgertons, they must concoct a new secret self for her to present to the outside world.
The Epilogues, however, show that any external ostracism they encountered has had little impact on Benedict and Sophie’s domestic happiness or social standing. Sophie has been embraced by Lady Whistledown, which is a seal of approval. Ending the last chapter with Lady Whistledown sets the stage for the next book in the Bridgerton series, Romancing Mister Bridgerton, in which the identity of Lady Whistledown becomes a central concern. Additionally, the Epilogues present reproduction and childbearing as the ultimate proof of a contented heterosexual marriage.
Related Titles
By Julia Quinn
